python / python/cpython

`ast.class._field_types` causes Exception when `ast.class._fields` does not cause Exception

オープン
#135,797 コメント 6 件 リアクション 0 件 担当者 0 名 GitHub で見る

まだ誰も着手していません。

interpreter-core triaged type-bug type-feature
主要言語
Python
スター
77.2k
フォーク
35.9k
PR 指標を取得中

説明

Bug report

Bug description:

_field and _field_types behave differently

Accessing the _field_types attribute of an ast.AST subclass will cause an exception if the class has no _fields, but accessing the _fields attribute never causes an exception.

Example: ast.mod

(.venv) C:\clones\cpython>py
Python 3.13.5 (tags/v3.13.5:6cb20a2, Jun 11 2025, 16:15:46) [MSC v.1943 64 bit (AMD64)] on win32
Type "help", "copyright", "credits" or "license" for more information.
>>> import ast
>>> ast.mod._fields
()
>>> ast.mod._field_types
Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "<python-input-2>", line 1, in <module>
    ast.mod._field_types
AttributeError: type object 'mod' has no attribute '_field_types'
>>>

_field and _field_types for all ast.AST subclasses

Details 

(.venv) C:\clones\cpython>C:\clones\cpython\.venv\Scripts\python.exe c:/clones/cpython/field_types.py
3.13.5 (tags/v3.13.5:6cb20a2, Jun 11 2025, 16:15:46) [MSC v.1943 64 bit (AMD64)]

astClass._fields
AST ()
mod ()
stmt ()
expr ()
expr_context ()
boolop ()
operator ()
unaryop ()
cmpop ()
comprehension ('target', 'iter', 'ifs', 'is_async')
excepthandler ()
arguments ('posonlyargs', 'args', 'vararg', 'kwonlyargs', 'kw_defaults', 'kwarg', 'defaults')
arg ('arg', 'annotation', 'type_comment')
keyword ('arg', 'value')
alias ('name', 'asname')
withitem ('context_expr', 'optional_vars')
match_case ('pattern', 'guard', 'body')
pattern ()
type_ignore ()
type_param ()
slice ()
Num ('n',)
Str ('s',)
Bytes ('s',)
NameConstant ('value', 'kind')
Ellipsis ()
Module ('body', 'type_ignores')
Interactive ('body',)
Expression ('body',)
FunctionType ('argtypes', 'returns')
Suite ()
FunctionDef ('name', 'args', 'body', 'decorator_list', 'returns', 'type_comment', 'type_params')
AsyncFunctionDef ('name', 'args', 'body', 'decorator_list', 'returns', 'type_comment', 'type_params')
ClassDef ('name', 'bases', 'keywords', 'body', 'decorator_list', 'type_params')
Return ('value',)
Delete ('targets',)
Assign ('targets', 'value', 'type_comment')
TypeAlias ('name', 'type_params', 'value')
AugAssign ('target', 'op', 'value')
AnnAssign ('target', 'annotation', 'value', 'simple')
For ('target', 'iter', 'body', 'orelse', 'type_comment')
AsyncFor ('target', 'iter', 'body', 'orelse', 'type_comment')
While ('test', 'body', 'orelse')
If ('test', 'body', 'orelse')
With ('items', 'body', 'type_comment')
AsyncWith ('items', 'body', 'type_comment')
Match ('subject', 'cases')
Raise ('exc', 'cause')
Try ('body', 'handlers', 'orelse', 'finalbody')
TryStar ('body', 'handlers', 'orelse', 'finalbody')
Assert ('test', 'msg')
Import ('names',)
ImportFrom ('module', 'names', 'level')
Global ('names',)
Nonlocal ('names',)
Expr ('value',)
Pass ()
Break ()
Continue ()
BoolOp ('op', 'values')
NamedExpr ('target', 'value')
BinOp ('left', 'op', 'right')
UnaryOp ('op', 'operand')
Lambda ('args', 'body')
IfExp ('test', 'body', 'orelse')
Dict ('keys', 'values')
Set ('elts',)
ListComp ('elt', 'generators')
SetComp ('elt', 'generators')
DictComp ('key', 'value', 'generators')
GeneratorExp ('elt', 'generators')
Await ('value',)
Yield ('value',)
YieldFrom ('value',)
Compare ('left', 'ops', 'comparators')
Call ('func', 'args', 'keywords')
FormattedValue ('value', 'conversion', 'format_spec')
JoinedStr ('values',)
Constant ('value', 'kind')
Attribute ('value', 'attr', 'ctx')
Subscript ('value', 'slice', 'ctx')
Starred ('value', 'ctx')
Name ('id', 'ctx')
List ('elts', 'ctx')
Tuple ('elts', 'ctx')
Slice ('lower', 'upper', 'step')
Load ()
Store ()
Del ()
AugLoad ()
AugStore ()
Param ()
And ()
Or ()
Add ()
Sub ()
Mult ()
MatMult ()
Div ()
Mod ()
Pow ()
LShift ()
RShift ()
BitOr ()
BitXor ()
BitAnd ()
FloorDiv ()
Invert ()
Not ()
UAdd ()
USub ()
Eq ()
NotEq ()
Lt ()
LtE ()
Gt ()
GtE ()
Is ()
IsNot ()
In ()
NotIn ()
ExceptHandler ('type', 'name', 'body')
MatchValue ('value',)
MatchSingleton ('value',)
MatchSequence ('patterns',)
MatchMapping ('keys', 'patterns', 'rest')
MatchClass ('cls', 'patterns', 'kwd_attrs', 'kwd_patterns')
MatchStar ('name',)
MatchAs ('pattern', 'name')
MatchOr ('patterns',)
TypeIgnore ('lineno', 'tag')
TypeVar ('name', 'bound', 'default_value')
ParamSpec ('name', 'default_value')
TypeVarTuple ('name', 'default_value')
Index ()
ExtSlice ()
countExceptions = 0

astClass._field_types
AttributeError: AST
AttributeError: mod
AttributeError: stmt
AttributeError: expr
AttributeError: expr_context
AttributeError: boolop
AttributeError: operator
AttributeError: unaryop
AttributeError: cmpop
comprehension {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'iter': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ifs': list[ast.expr], 'is_async': <class 'int'>}
AttributeError: excepthandler
arguments {'posonlyargs': list[ast.arg], 'args': list[ast.arg], 'vararg': ast.arg | None, 'kwonlyargs': list[ast.arg], 'kw_defaults': list[ast.expr], 'kwarg': ast.arg | None, 'defaults': list[ast.expr]}
arg {'arg': <class 'str'>, 'annotation': ast.expr | None, 'type_comment': str | None}
keyword {'arg': str | None, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
alias {'name': <class 'str'>, 'asname': str | None}
withitem {'context_expr': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'optional_vars': ast.expr | None}
match_case {'pattern': <class 'ast.pattern'>, 'guard': ast.expr | None, 'body': list[ast.stmt]}
AttributeError: pattern
AttributeError: type_ignore
AttributeError: type_param
AttributeError: slice
Num {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
Str {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
Bytes {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
NameConstant {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
Ellipsis {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
Module {'body': list[ast.stmt], 'type_ignores': list[ast.type_ignore]}
Interactive {'body': list[ast.stmt]}
Expression {'body': <class 'ast.expr'>}
FunctionType {'argtypes': list[ast.expr], 'returns': <class 'ast.expr'>}
AttributeError: Suite
FunctionDef {'name': <class 'str'>, 'args': <class 'ast.arguments'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'decorator_list': list[ast.expr], 'returns': ast.expr | None, 'type_comment': str | None, 'type_params': list[ast.type_param]}
AsyncFunctionDef {'name': <class 'str'>, 'args': <class 'ast.arguments'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'decorator_list': list[ast.expr], 'returns': ast.expr | None, 'type_comment': str | None, 'type_params': list[ast.type_param]}
ClassDef {'name': <class 'str'>, 'bases': list[ast.expr], 'keywords': list[ast.keyword], 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'decorator_list': list[ast.expr], 'type_params': list[ast.type_param]}
Return {'value': ast.expr | None}
Delete {'targets': list[ast.expr]}
Assign {'targets': list[ast.expr], 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'type_comment': str | None}
TypeAlias {'name': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'type_params': list[ast.type_param], 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
AugAssign {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'op': <class 'ast.operator'>, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
AnnAssign {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'annotation': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'value': ast.expr | None, 'simple': <class 'int'>}
For {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'iter': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
AsyncFor {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'iter': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
While {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt]}
If {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt]}
With {'items': list[ast.withitem], 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
AsyncWith {'items': list[ast.withitem], 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
Match {'subject': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'cases': list[ast.match_case]}
Raise {'exc': ast.expr | None, 'cause': ast.expr | None}
Try {'body': list[ast.stmt], 'handlers': list[ast.excepthandler], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'finalbody': list[ast.stmt]}
TryStar {'body': list[ast.stmt], 'handlers': list[ast.excepthandler], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'finalbody': list[ast.stmt]}
Assert {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'msg': ast.expr | None}
Import {'names': list[ast.alias]}
ImportFrom {'module': str | None, 'names': list[ast.alias], 'level': int | None}
Global {'names': list[str]}
Nonlocal {'names': list[str]}
Expr {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Pass {}
Break {}
Continue {}
BoolOp {'op': <class 'ast.boolop'>, 'values': list[ast.expr]}
NamedExpr {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
BinOp {'left': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'op': <class 'ast.operator'>, 'right': <class 'ast.expr'>}
UnaryOp {'op': <class 'ast.unaryop'>, 'operand': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Lambda {'args': <class 'ast.arguments'>, 'body': <class 'ast.expr'>}
IfExp {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'orelse': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Dict {'keys': list[ast.expr], 'values': list[ast.expr]}
Set {'elts': list[ast.expr]}
ListComp {'elt': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
SetComp {'elt': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
DictComp {'key': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
GeneratorExp {'elt': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
Await {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Yield {'value': ast.expr | None}
YieldFrom {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Compare {'left': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ops': list[ast.cmpop], 'comparators': list[ast.expr]}
Call {'func': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'args': list[ast.expr], 'keywords': list[ast.keyword]}
FormattedValue {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'conversion': <class 'int'>, 'format_spec': ast.expr | None}
JoinedStr {'values': list[ast.expr]}
Constant {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
Attribute {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'attr': <class 'str'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Subscript {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'slice': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Starred {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Name {'id': <class 'str'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
List {'elts': list[ast.expr], 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Tuple {'elts': list[ast.expr], 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Slice {'lower': ast.expr | None, 'upper': ast.expr | None, 'step': ast.expr | None}
Load {}
Store {}
Del {}
AttributeError: AugLoad
AttributeError: AugStore
AttributeError: Param
And {}
Or {}
Add {}
Sub {}
Mult {}
MatMult {}
Div {}
Mod {}
Pow {}
LShift {}
RShift {}
BitOr {}
BitXor {}
BitAnd {}
FloorDiv {}
Invert {}
Not {}
UAdd {}
USub {}
Eq {}
NotEq {}
Lt {}
LtE {}
Gt {}
GtE {}
Is {}
IsNot {}
In {}
NotIn {}
ExceptHandler {'type': ast.expr | None, 'name': str | None, 'body': list[ast.stmt]}
MatchValue {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
MatchSingleton {'value': <class 'object'>}
MatchSequence {'patterns': list[ast.pattern]}
MatchMapping {'keys': list[ast.expr], 'patterns': list[ast.pattern], 'rest': str | None}
MatchClass {'cls': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'patterns': list[ast.pattern], 'kwd_attrs': list[str], 'kwd_patterns': list[ast.pattern]}
MatchStar {'name': str | None}
MatchAs {'pattern': ast.pattern | None, 'name': str | None}
MatchOr {'patterns': list[ast.pattern]}
TypeIgnore {'lineno': <class 'int'>, 'tag': <class 'str'>}
TypeVar {'name': <class 'str'>, 'bound': ast.expr | None, 'default_value': ast.expr | None}
ParamSpec {'name': <class 'str'>, 'default_value': ast.expr | None}
TypeVarTuple {'name': <class 'str'>, 'default_value': ast.expr | None}
AttributeError: Index
AttributeError: ExtSlice
countExceptions = 20

No errors after code changes

After adding logic to "Parser/asdl_c.py" to treat _field_types similar to _fields, the exceptions were replaced with empty dictionaries.

Summary

(.venv) C:\clones\cpython>C:\clones\cpython\python c:/clones/cpython/field_types.py
Running Debug|x64 interpreter...
3.15.0a0 (heads/main-dirty:b14986c9146, Jun 21 2025, 15:02:00) [MSC v.1944 64 bit (AMD64)]

astClass._fields
countExceptions = 0

astClass._field_types
countExceptions = 0

_field_types for all ast.AST subclasses

Details 

AST {}
mod {}
stmt {}
expr {}
expr_context {}
boolop {}
operator {}
unaryop {}
cmpop {}
comprehension {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'iter': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ifs': list[ast.expr], 'is_async': <class 'int'>}
excepthandler {}
arguments {'posonlyargs': list[ast.arg], 'args': list[ast.arg], 'vararg': ast.arg | None, 'kwonlyargs': list[ast.arg], 'kw_defaults': list[ast.expr], 'kwarg': ast.arg | None, 'defaults': list[ast.expr]}
arg {'arg': <class 'str'>, 'annotation': ast.expr | None, 'type_comment': str | None}
keyword {'arg': str | None, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
alias {'name': <class 'str'>, 'asname': str | None}
withitem {'context_expr': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'optional_vars': ast.expr | None}
match_case {'pattern': <class 'ast.pattern'>, 'guard': ast.expr | None, 'body': list[ast.stmt]}
pattern {}
type_ignore {}
type_param {}
slice {}
Module {'body': list[ast.stmt], 'type_ignores': list[ast.type_ignore]}
Interactive {'body': list[ast.stmt]}
Expression {'body': <class 'ast.expr'>}
FunctionType {'argtypes': list[ast.expr], 'returns': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Suite {}
FunctionDef {'name': <class 'str'>, 'args': <class 'ast.arguments'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'decorator_list': list[ast.expr], 'returns': ast.expr | None, 'type_comment': str | None, 'type_params': list[ast.type_param]}
AsyncFunctionDef {'name': <class 'str'>, 'args': <class 'ast.arguments'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'decorator_list': list[ast.expr], 'returns': ast.expr | None, 'type_comment': str | None, 'type_params': list[ast.type_param]}
ClassDef {'name': <class 'str'>, 'bases': list[ast.expr], 'keywords': list[ast.keyword], 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'decorator_list': list[ast.expr], 'type_params': list[ast.type_param]}
Return {'value': ast.expr | None}
Delete {'targets': list[ast.expr]}
Assign {'targets': list[ast.expr], 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'type_comment': str | None}
TypeAlias {'name': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'type_params': list[ast.type_param], 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
AugAssign {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'op': <class 'ast.operator'>, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
AnnAssign {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'annotation': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'value': ast.expr | None, 'simple': <class 'int'>}
For {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'iter': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
AsyncFor {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'iter': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
While {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt]}
If {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt]}
With {'items': list[ast.withitem], 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
AsyncWith {'items': list[ast.withitem], 'body': list[ast.stmt], 'type_comment': str | None}
Match {'subject': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'cases': list[ast.match_case]}
Raise {'exc': ast.expr | None, 'cause': ast.expr | None}
Try {'body': list[ast.stmt], 'handlers': list[ast.excepthandler], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'finalbody': list[ast.stmt]}
TryStar {'body': list[ast.stmt], 'handlers': list[ast.excepthandler], 'orelse': list[ast.stmt], 'finalbody': list[ast.stmt]}
Assert {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'msg': ast.expr | None}
Import {'names': list[ast.alias]}
ImportFrom {'module': str | None, 'names': list[ast.alias], 'level': int | None}
Global {'names': list[str]}
Nonlocal {'names': list[str]}
Expr {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Pass {}
Break {}
Continue {}
BoolOp {'op': <class 'ast.boolop'>, 'values': list[ast.expr]}
NamedExpr {'target': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
BinOp {'left': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'op': <class 'ast.operator'>, 'right': <class 'ast.expr'>}
UnaryOp {'op': <class 'ast.unaryop'>, 'operand': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Lambda {'args': <class 'ast.arguments'>, 'body': <class 'ast.expr'>}
IfExp {'test': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'body': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'orelse': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Dict {'keys': list[ast.expr], 'values': list[ast.expr]}
Set {'elts': list[ast.expr]}
ListComp {'elt': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
SetComp {'elt': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
DictComp {'key': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
GeneratorExp {'elt': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'generators': list[ast.comprehension]}
Await {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Yield {'value': ast.expr | None}
YieldFrom {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
Compare {'left': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ops': list[ast.cmpop], 'comparators': list[ast.expr]}
Call {'func': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'args': list[ast.expr], 'keywords': list[ast.keyword]}
FormattedValue {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'conversion': <class 'int'>, 'format_spec': ast.expr | None}
Interpolation {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'str': <class 'object'>, 'conversion': <class 'int'>, 'format_spec': ast.expr | None}
JoinedStr {'values': list[ast.expr]}
TemplateStr {'values': list[ast.expr]}
Constant {'value': <class 'object'>, 'kind': str | None}
Attribute {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'attr': <class 'str'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Subscript {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'slice': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Starred {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Name {'id': <class 'str'>, 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
List {'elts': list[ast.expr], 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Tuple {'elts': list[ast.expr], 'ctx': <class 'ast.expr_context'>}
Slice {'lower': ast.expr | None, 'upper': ast.expr | None, 'step': ast.expr | None}
Load {}
Store {}
Del {}
AugLoad {}
AugStore {}
Param {}
And {}
Or {}
Add {}
Sub {}
Mult {}
MatMult {}
Div {}
Mod {}
Pow {}
LShift {}
RShift {}
BitOr {}
BitXor {}
BitAnd {}
FloorDiv {}
Invert {}
Not {}
UAdd {}
USub {}
Eq {}
NotEq {}
Lt {}
LtE {}
Gt {}
GtE {}
Is {}
IsNot {}
In {}
NotIn {}
ExceptHandler {'type': ast.expr | None, 'name': str | None, 'body': list[ast.stmt]}
MatchValue {'value': <class 'ast.expr'>}
MatchSingleton {'value': <class 'object'>}
MatchSequence {'patterns': list[ast.pattern]}
MatchMapping {'keys': list[ast.expr], 'patterns': list[ast.pattern], 'rest': str | None}
MatchClass {'cls': <class 'ast.expr'>, 'patterns': list[ast.pattern], 'kwd_attrs': list[str], 'kwd_patterns': list[ast.pattern]}
MatchStar {'name': str | None}
MatchAs {'pattern': ast.pattern | None, 'name': str | None}
MatchOr {'patterns': list[ast.pattern]}
TypeIgnore {'lineno': <class 'int'>, 'tag': <class 'str'>}
TypeVar {'name': <class 'str'>, 'bound': ast.expr | None, 'default_value': ast.expr | None}
ParamSpec {'name': <class 'str'>, 'default_value': ast.expr | None}
TypeVarTuple {'name': <class 'str'>, 'default_value': ast.expr | None}
Index {}
ExtSlice {}
countExceptions = 0

Check for errors on branches

Not applicable to 3.9, 3.10, 3.11, 3.12.

Branch 3.13

Details 

(.venv) C:\clones\cpython>C:\clones\cpython\python c:/clones/cpython/field_types.py
Running Debug|x64 interpreter...
3.13.5+ (heads/3.13:4eab9da960d, Jun 21 2025, 14:44:53) [MSC v.1944 64 bit (AMD64)]

astClass._fields
countExceptions = 0

astClass._field_types
AttributeError: AST
AttributeError: mod
AttributeError: stmt
AttributeError: expr
AttributeError: expr_context
AttributeError: boolop
AttributeError: operator
AttributeError: unaryop
AttributeError: cmpop
AttributeError: excepthandler
AttributeError: pattern
AttributeError: type_ignore
AttributeError: type_param
AttributeError: slice
AttributeError: Suite
AttributeError: AugLoad
AttributeError: AugStore
AttributeError: Param
AttributeError: Index
AttributeError: ExtSlice
countExceptions = 20

Branch 3.14

Details 

(.venv) C:\clones\cpython>C:\clones\cpython\python c:/clones/cpython/field_types.py
Running Debug|x64 interpreter...
3.14.0b3+ (heads/3.14:73e2089ed13, Jun 21 2025, 14:57:19) [MSC v.1944 64 bit (AMD64)]

astClass._fields
countExceptions = 0

astClass._field_types
AttributeError: AST
AttributeError: mod
AttributeError: stmt
AttributeError: expr
AttributeError: expr_context
AttributeError: boolop
AttributeError: operator
AttributeError: unaryop
AttributeError: cmpop
AttributeError: excepthandler
AttributeError: pattern
AttributeError: type_ignore
AttributeError: type_param
AttributeError: slice
AttributeError: Suite
AttributeError: AugLoad
AttributeError: AugStore
AttributeError: Param
AttributeError: Index
AttributeError: ExtSlice
countExceptions = 20

Branch main

Details 

(.venv) C:\clones\cpython>C:\clones\cpython\python c:/clones/cpython/field_types.py
Running Debug|x64 interpreter...
3.15.0a0 (heads/main:b14986c9146, Jun 21 2025, 14:59:45) [MSC v.1944 64 bit (AMD64)]

astClass._fields
countExceptions = 0

astClass._field_types
AttributeError: AST
AttributeError: mod
AttributeError: stmt
AttributeError: expr
AttributeError: expr_context
AttributeError: boolop
AttributeError: operator
AttributeError: unaryop
AttributeError: cmpop
AttributeError: excepthandler
AttributeError: pattern
AttributeError: type_ignore
AttributeError: type_param
AttributeError: slice
AttributeError: Suite
AttributeError: AugLoad
AttributeError: AugStore
AttributeError: Param
AttributeError: Index
AttributeError: ExtSlice
countExceptions = 20

Python code used to generate the above tests

Details 

from itertools import chain
import ast
import sys

print(sys.version, end='\n\n')

countExceptions = 0
print('astClass._fields')
for astClass in [C for C in [ast.AST,*chain(*(c.__subclasses__() for c in [ast.AST,ast.Constant,*ast.AST.__subclasses__()]))] if issubclass(C,ast.AST)]:
	try:
		print(astClass.__name__, astClass._fields)
		# astClass._fields
	except AttributeError as ERRORmessage:
		print(ERRORmessage.__class__.__name__, astClass.__name__, sep=': ')
		countExceptions += 1
print(f"{countExceptions = }\n")

countExceptions = 0
print('astClass._field_types')
for astClass in [C for C in [ast.AST,*chain(*(c.__subclasses__() for c in [ast.AST,ast.Constant,*ast.AST.__subclasses__()]))] if issubclass(C,ast.AST)]:
	try:
		print(astClass.__name__, astClass._field_types)
		# astClass._field_types
	except AttributeError as ERRORmessage:
		print(ERRORmessage.__class__.__name__, astClass.__name__, sep=': ')
		countExceptions += 1
print(f"{countExceptions = }")

CPython versions tested on:

3.13, 3.14, CPython main branch

Operating systems tested on:

Windows

Linked PRs
  • gh-135800

コントリビューションガイド

コントリビューションガイドを開く

はじめの一歩

  1. issue を最後まで読み、次にプロジェクトのコントリビューションガイドを読みます。
  2. 着手することを issue にコメントします — 二人が同じ作業をするのを防げます。
  3. リポジトリをフォークし、ブランチを切って変更します。
  4. issue 番号を参照したプルリクエストを送ります。

調査の方向性

Parser/asdl_c.py から始めます。ここでは、issue で _field_types を _fields と同じように扱うロジックの追加が報告されています。対象のインタープリターで、言及されている field_types.py スクリプトを実行し、フィールドがある場合とない場合の AST サブクラスを比較します。報告された AttributeError のケースが空の辞書に置き換えられ、スクリプトの出力にエラーがなければ完了です。

索引モデルが issue の本文から書いたものです。

評価

技術スタック
python
領域
compilers
issue の種類
バグ
難易度
3/5
見積もり時間
1〜2日
活発さ
停滞
明瞭さ
おおむね明確
初心者へのやさしさ
35/100

新しい issue をメールで受け取る

初心者向けの GitHub issue を短くまとめたダイジェスト。