TextDecoder is wrong and very slow

Correctness

Encodings that return invalid results:

• Single-byte:
  • ibm866 (fails at even ascii input)
  • koi8-u
  • windows-874
  • windows-1252
  • windows-1253
  • windows-1255
• Multi-byte (all except gb18030):
  • gbk (should be identical to gb18030 but it is instead broken)
  • big5
  • euc-jp
  • iso-2022-jp
  • shift_jis (fails at even ascii input)
  • euc-kr

Unimplemented encodings that throw:

• iso-8859-16
• x-user-defined

If built without icu, utf-16le encoding also returns invalid results:

> new TextDecoder('utf-16le').decode(Uint16Array.of(0xd800))
'�' // correct
'\ud800' // no ICU

Performance

• utf-8 (aka default) TextDecoder is much slower on ascii input than it can and should be
  1.3x on 4096 bytes, ~3x on 1 MiB input
• The above applies to buffer.toString() too
  It's much slower on ASCII input than a checked js impl (same 1.3x-3x)
• windows-1252 aka new TextDecoder('ascii') aka new TextDecoder('latin1')
  is ~2x-4x slower than an optimized impl on ascii input
• windows-1252 aka new TextDecoder('latin1')
  is ~6x-12x slower than an optimized impl on latin1 input
• windows-1252 is ~7x-12x slower than an optimized js impl
• Other single-byte encodings that are significantly slower than js impl even on non-ascii input:
  iso-8859-3, iso-8859-6, iso-8859-7, iso-8859-8, iso-8859-8-i, windows-1253, windows-1255, windows-1257
• None of the single-byte encodings are faster than the js impl even on non-ascii input
• All of the single-byte encodings except windows-1252 are >=10x slower than the js impl on ascii input
  (windows-1252 is only ~2-4x slower)

References

Nothing of the above requires any changes on the native side, I compared to a somewhat optimized JS implementation

See https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pdEefRG6r9fZy61WHGz0TKSt8cO4ISWqlpBN5KntIvQ/edit

See tests in https://github.com/ExodusOSS/bytes/blob/master/tests/encoding/mistakes.test.js (comment out the import and it can be run on Node.js without deps with only that file)

Suggestions

1. Add a proper ASCII fast path to buffer.toString()
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61119
2. Add a proper ASCII fast path to new TextDecoder().decode(arg)
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61119
3. Perhaps replace single-byte decoders with a js impl, remove native paths and lib usage. They all are just mappers, the implementation for all of them is identical
   Or at least replace the slow, unsupported, or invalid ones.
   #61093
4. Remove gbk decoder path and make it do the same as gb18030 as the spec says
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61099
5. For utf16 decode optimistically using existing fast apis, then check the string for validity
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61559
6. Fix bugs in the non-ICU codepath
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61409
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61549
   https://github.com/nodejs/node/pull/61559
7. Fix or replace implementations for big5, euc-jp, iso-2022-jp, shift_jis, euc-kr
   To fix legacy multi-byte decoders, attempt to re-use what Chromium has or import js code from @exodus/bytes

Comienza con los puntos de entrada TextDecoder y buffer.toString() descritos en el issue y, después, ejecuta las pruebas de codificación de bytes referenciadas para reproducir un fallo específico de corrección o medir un caso específico de rendimiento. Limita el trabajo a una codificación o fast path, y define que el trabajo está terminado cuando se supere la prueba de corrección relevante o se demuestre la mejora prevista, sin cambiar rutas del decoder no relacionadas.