Socket Mode: reconnects behind NAT leak server-side connection registrations → too_many_websockets cap → silent loss of interactive payloads; mitigation proposals

Slack SDK version: slack-sdk 3.43.0, slack-bolt 1.29.0
Python: 3.13 (aiohttp Socket Mode client)
OS/platform: Linux container (Docker) on macOS host, behind NAT

Summary

This is part bug report, part mitigation proposal, backed by wire-level data.
When SocketModeClient reconnects while the network path is degraded (half-open
TCP: the close frame never reaches Slack), the old connection remains registered
server-side for an extended period. Repeated reconnects therefore accumulate
"ghost" registrations up to Slack's 10-connection cap (disconnect: too_many_websockets). Slack then delivers envelopes across all registered
connections, so most interactive (block_actions) payloads — which unlike
events are not retried on non-ack — are silently lost. From the app's
perspective the client looks perfectly healthy: ping/pong fine, events flowing.

Wire evidence

(from a run_message_listeners wrapper logging hello and disconnect frames)

• fresh start: hello reports num_connections=1
• ~1.5 h later, on a reconnect: 3x disconnect reason=too_many_websockets,
  then hello num_connections=10 — while the process verifiably held ONE
  established TCP connection to Slack the whole time
• ghost registrations age out at roughly one per 30-45 minutes
• while num_connections is high, most button clicks never arrive on any
  connection we hold; with a clean pool, every click arrives (tested across
  message sizes 0.5-5 KB — size is irrelevant)
• reproduced on a SECOND app in the same workspace: first hello after a
  process restart reported num_connections=7 for an app that also runs as a
  single instance
• observed approximate_connection_time (inside hello.debug_info) is
  consistently 18060 (~5 h), which sets the ghost age-out horizon

Why this is hard to see with the current SDK

1. The hello envelope (carrying num_connections) never reaches
   message_listeners — SocketModeRequest.from_dict requires
   type+envelope_id+payload, so apps cannot observe the most important signal
   without wrapping internals.
2. disconnect frames (including too_many_websockets) are handled by
   run_message_listeners before the listener loop and only visible at debug
   logging.
3. A degraded connection still passes is_connected() / ping-pong checks, so
   client-side health monitoring cannot detect the server-side pool state.

Proposals (any subset would help)

1. Surface hello metadata (num_connections, approximate_connection_time,
   host) and disconnect reasons via a public callback or at INFO logging.
2. Emit a loud warning when num_connections in hello exceeds a threshold
   (e.g., 4) while the client manages fewer connections — this is direct
   evidence of ghost registrations and imminent interactive-payload loss.
3. Consider make-before-break reconnects with close-confirmation, or documenting
   that reconnect-heavy operation behind NAT can poison the server-side pool.
4. Still-open PRs #1914 / #1926 address orphaned client-side sessions in the
   same failure family — this issue is their server-side counterpart, and since
   neither is merged/released (latest release is 3.43.0), apps currently have no
   upstream remedy at all; that raises the priority of surfacing the diagnostics
   from proposals 1-2.

Happy to share full logs and reproduction notes. We have also filed a parallel
report with Slack developer support regarding the server-side routing/eviction
behavior; will cross-link.

Trước tiên, hãy lần theo run_message_listeners và SocketModeRequest.from_dict, tập trung vào cách siêu dữ liệu hello và các lý do ngắt kết nối được xử lý trước khi các listener của thông báo nhận các frame. Nếu có thể, hãy tái hiện hành vi kết nối lại, sau đó xác định các chẩn đoán hiển thị số lượng kết nối phía máy chủ và các lý do đủ rõ ràng để cảnh báo về một pool không lành mạnh.