SocketModeClient.connect() retries forever against a permanently closed aiohttp ClientSession

Title

SocketModeClient.connect() retries forever against a permanently closed aiohttp ClientSession

Environment

• slack_sdk 3.43.0
• File: slack_sdk/socket_mode/aiohttp/__init__.py
• Relevant locations: session creation ~L130, is_connected() ~L321-334, connect() ~L347-409, close() ~L446-457

Description

SocketModeClient (aiohttp implementation) keeps a single aiohttp.ClientSession for the client's entire lifetime — a reasonable design, per the comment at its creation: "it is suggested you use a single session for the lifetime of your application, to benefit from connection pooling." The bug isn't that design choice; it's that the unbounded retry loop doesn't handle that session ever entering a closed state.

connect() wraps reconnection attempts in while True: (~L352). On exception it logs "Failed to connect (error: {e}); Retrying..." (~L408) and loops again, reusing self.aiohttp_client_session. If that session itself has been closed (not just the individual WebSocket tracked as self.current_session), every subsequent retry fails identically forever with RuntimeError: Session is closed — nothing inside this loop ever recreates the session; that only happens when a new SocketModeClient instance is constructed from scratch.

Separately, is_connected() checks self.current_session/ping-pong state but does not check self.aiohttp_client_session.closed, so downstream consumers building their own health checks or watchdogs on top of this client have no way to detect this specific failure mode without reaching into a private-ish attribute themselves.

Impact observed

In production, a consumer application's own reconnect watchdog (checking is_connected()) never detected this state, because the WebSocket layer could still look "connected enough" (some event types were still being delivered) while the HTTP session underneath was permanently dead. The client was stuck retrying every ~10 seconds for over 24 hours with no self-healing, until the whole process was restarted externally.

Likely forced repro (not yet reduced to a minimal script)

1. Construct a SocketModeClient with a valid app token; await client.connect().
2. await client.aiohttp_client_session.close() (or otherwise force it closed) while the connection is established.
3. Trigger a reconnect attempt (e.g. disconnect the network, or otherwise cause connect()'s loop to retry).
4. Observe it fails forever: Failed to connect (error: Session is closed); Retrying...
5. Observe is_connected() may not reflect the problem if self.current_session (the WebSocket) hasn't itself been marked closed/None.

Suggested fixes (ranked)

1. Preferred: in connect()'s retry loop, check self.aiohttp_client_session.closed at the top of each iteration; if closed, recreate it (e.g. re-instantiate aiohttp.ClientSession) before retrying ws_connect.
2. Minimum: if recreating isn't desired, raise or break out of the loop when the session is closed, so the caller can rebuild the whole client instead of retrying forever against a dead one.
3. Consumer-facing improvement: reflect aiohttp_client_session.closed in is_connected() (or an equivalent health-check property), so consumers can detect this without reaching into a non-public attribute.

Notes

We don't have a minimal standalone repro yet — this was diagnosed from production logs plus reading this source after a ~39 hour incident where a single client instance got stuck in this state. Happy to help characterize a repro further if useful. We've worked around this downstream by having our own consumer explicitly check aiohttp_client_session.closed before deciding whether to rebuild — happy to link that once it's merged, in case the pattern is useful context here too.

Bắt đầu trong slack_sdk/socket_mode/aiohttp/init.py tại phần tạo session (~L130), is_connected() (~L321-334), connect() (~L347-409) và close() (~L446-457). Tái hiện tình huống session bị đóng cưỡng chế và theo dõi vòng lặp thử lại; được xem là hoàn tất khi client không còn thử lại vô hạn đối với một session đã đóng và kiểm tra tình trạng phản ánh lỗi hoặc caller nhận được tín hiệu kết thúc rõ ràng.