pythonw should set `sys.stdout` and `sys.stdin` to valid objects.

Bug report

Bug description:

So not exactly a bug -- but I wouldn't call it a feature request either, so I filed it as a bug.

The issue is that pythonw on Windows sets sys.stdout and sys.stdin to None.

This is problematic because while, e.g. print() will not fail, if not do anything useful, other things like warnings and logging, etc., may try to use stdout or stderr, and they will then fail.

See #107792 and #57791

So one might say: "don't do that" -- fair enough, except the user suffering from the problem may not be the one that wrote the code that's calling stderr -- it could be in a library, for instance. Library writers are often not thinking about windowed apps, and shouldn't have to do something special to accommodate them in any case.

See this note in the PyInstaller docs:

https://pyinstaller.org/en/stable/common-issues-and-pitfalls.html?highlight=os.devnull#sys-stdin-sys-stdout-and-sys-stderr-in-noconsole-windowed-applications-windows-only

In which the solution is:

import sys
import os

if sys.stdout is None:
    sys.stdout = open(os.devnull, "w")
if sys.stderr is None:
    sys.stderr = open(os.devnull, "w")

It's not unreasonable for library authors to expect that stdout and stderr to be valid.

So couldn't pythonw add that code by default? users could override it themselves, of course.

NOTE: tested recently on py3.12 -- but this has been an issue for quite some time.

NOTE2: this isn't an issue on the Mac, because its pythonw redirects to the system off-screen console.

CPython versions tested on:

3.12

Operating systems tested on:

Windows

まず Windows で pythonw を使って動作を再現し、issue にリンクされている議論と、標準ストリームが存在しない場合についての PyInstaller ドキュメントを確認します。既存の動作を壊さずに pythonw が有効な sys.stdin オブジェクトと sys.stdout オブジェクトを提供する方法を判断し、そのうえで警告、ロギング、print に関連するユースケースが期待どおりに動作することを検証します。