Unhandled error in sys.excepthook

• Bitbucket: https://bitbucket.org/hpk42/execnet/issue/30
• Originally reported by: @alfredodeza
• Originally created at: 2014-02-10T16:05:34.775

After closing the connections we are seeing a few thread errors that seem impossible to get rid of. At the point where they are sent to stderr there is nothing left running and the code has closed the gateway.

Unhandled exception in thread started by
Error in sys.excepthook:

Original exception was:

Running execnet with debug show this:

[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] RECEIVERTHREAD: starting to run
[53488] gw0 sent <Message.CHANNEL_EXEC channelid=1 len=6354>
[53488] gw0 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'platform_information()'>
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 ('Ubuntu', '12.04', 'precise')>
[53488] gw0 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'machine_type()'>
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'x86_64'>
[53488] gw0 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'shortname()'>
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'node1'>
[53488] gw0 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 len=324>
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 None>
[53488] gw0 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 len=127>
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 None>
[53488] gw0 gateway.exit() called
[53488] gw0 --> sending GATEWAY_TERMINATE
[53488] gw0 --> io.close_write
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] EOF without prior gateway termination message
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] entering finalization
[53488] gw0 finished receiving
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] terminating execution
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] closing read
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] closing write
[53488] gw0 [receiver-thread] leaving finalization
[53488] gw1 [receiver-thread] RECEIVERTHREAD: starting to run
[53488] gw1 sent <Message.CHANNEL_EXEC channelid=1 len=6354>
[53488] gw1 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'platform_information()'>
[53488] gw1 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 ('CentOS', '6.4', 'Final')>
[53488] gw1 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'machine_type()'>
[53488] gw1 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'x86_64'>
[53488] gw1 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'shortname()'>
[53488] gw1 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 'node2'>
[53488] gw1 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 len=324>
[53488] gw1 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 None>
[53488] gw1 sent <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 len=127>
[53488] gw1 [receiver-thread] received <Message.CHANNEL_DATA channelid=1 None>
[53488] gw1 gateway.exit() called
[53488] gw1 --> sending GATEWAY_TERMINATE
[53488] gw1 --> io.close_write
[53488] === atexit cleanup <Group []> ===
[53488] gw0 1 channel.__del__
[53488] gw1 1 channel.__del__
Unhandled exception in thread started by
Error in sys.excepthook:

Original exception was:

It looks as though this is happening in the threading module in Python itself. I am not sure something is possible to eat up these messages.

There is a ticket open in the Python bug tracker that mentions this problem is closed:

http://bugs.python.org/issue1722344

One of the patches that one commenter added looks like what we would need to get rid of them (http://bugs.python.org/file9356/1722344_squelch_exception.patch)

--- /usr/lib/python2.5/threading.py.orig	2008-02-04 13:58:18.000000000 -0600
+++ ./threading.py	2008-02-05 11:55:33.000000000 -0600
@@ -472,34 +472,18 @@
                     _sys.stderr.write("Exception in thread %s:\n%s\n" %
                                       (self.getName(), _format_exc()))
                 else:
-                    # Do the best job possible w/o a huge amt. of code to
-                    # approximate a traceback (code ideas from
-                    # Lib/traceback.py)
-                    exc_type, exc_value, exc_tb = self.__exc_info()
-                    try:
-                        print>>self.__stderr, (
-                            "Exception in thread " + self.getName() +
-                            " (most likely raised during interpreter shutdown):")
-                        print>>self.__stderr, (
-                            "Traceback (most recent call last):")
-                        while exc_tb:
-                            print>>self.__stderr, (
-                                '  File "%s", line %s, in %s' %
-                                (exc_tb.tb_frame.f_code.co_filename,
-                                    exc_tb.tb_lineno,
-                                    exc_tb.tb_frame.f_code.co_name))
-                            exc_tb = exc_tb.tb_next
-                        print>>self.__stderr, ("%s: %s" % (exc_type, exc_value))
-                    # Make sure that exc_tb gets deleted since it is a memory
-                    # hog; deleting everything else is just for thoroughness
-                    finally:
-                        del exc_type, exc_value, exc_tb
+                    # If _sys is missing, then the interpreter is shutting
+                    # down and the thread should no longer exist.  If this
+                    # happens, ignore the error and exit gracefully.
+                    pass
             else:
                 if __debug__:
                     self._note("%s.__bootstrap(): normal return", self)
         finally:
-            self.__stop()
+            # Exceptions will also be raised during stop/delete if the
+            # interpreter is shutting down.  Ignore these as well.
             try:
+                self.__stop()
                 self.__delete()
             except:
                 pass

Beginne damit, die Shutdown-Sequenz mit der Debug-Ausgabe von execnet zu reproduzieren, wobei der Schwerpunkt auf gateway.exit(), der Finalisierung des Receiver-Threads und der im Bericht gezeigten atexit-Bereinigung liegt. Vergleiche die resultierenden Fehler mit dem Shutdown-Verhalten von Pythons threading und dem verknüpften threading.py-Patch. Erledigt ist die Aufgabe, wenn die Bereinigung beim Interpreter-Shutdown nicht mehr die Fehler wegen unbehandelter Threads und sys.excepthook ausgibt.