streamable-http client: no size bound before JSONRPCMessage.model_validate_json — one large server message can OOM the client

Summary

StreamableHTTPTransport parses every inbound SSE event and JSON response body with JSONRPCMessage.model_validate_json / model_validate_json(content) and no size bound. Because pydantic validation of a large JSON document allocates several times the wire size in live Python objects, a single oversized message from a server can exhaust the client's memory. There is no hook to inspect or reject a message before it is parsed.

We hit this in production: a client connected to ~30 MCP servers, one of which answered tools/list with a 21.9 MB single SSE event. Measured with tracemalloc at the parse site:

#1  663.4 MB in 9,957,044 blocks
    mcp/client/streamable_http.py:217
      message = JSONRPCMessage.model_validate_json(sse.data)
#2  46.9 MB in 3 blocks
    httpx_sse/_decoders.py:61   (whole event buffered as one string)
#3  46.9 MB in 2 blocks
    httpx_sse/_decoders.py:120  (copy from slicing)

Roughly a 7× amplification of the wire size in live objects, transient but concurrent with other parses. A trivial request that triggered only catalogue loading peaked at 2.35 GB RSS from a 56 MB baseline; heavier concurrent work reached 4.2 GB. Removing that one server dropped the same request's peak to 456 MB. Versions: mcp 1.27.1, Python 3.14.

Why a client-side bound is needed

The client cannot know in advance that a server will return a huge payload, and a misbehaving or misconfigured server should not be able to OOM its client. Today the only outcome is process death with nothing identifying the responsible server — the failure surfaces as an unexplained kill rather than an actionable error.

What we did as a workaround, and why it was awkward

We wrapped StreamableHTTPTransport._handle_sse_event and _handle_json_response to measure sse.data / the response body and reject anything over a configured cap before parsing. Two things made this harder than expected, and both seem worth addressing upstream:

1. Raising from the handler is not viable. Every call site wraps it in except Exception: logger.debug(...) and then reconnects with Last-Event-ID, which replays the same oversized payload. The raise is swallowed and the pending request hangs.
2. Delivering a bare Exception on the read stream does not fail the request either. In BaseSession._receive_loop, isinstance(message, Exception) routes to _handle_incoming, which for the default message handler is a no-op; only a JSONRPCResponse/JSONRPCError matching _response_streams[request_id] completes send_request, and that awaits with timeout=None. To fail the request we had to synthesize a JSONRPCError and recover the request id from the raw payload with a regex, since parsing it is exactly what we were trying to avoid.

Suggested improvements

• An optional client-side maximum message size (constructor argument and/or environment variable) enforced before model_validate_json, on both the SSE and application/json paths.
• When it trips, fail the corresponding pending request with a distinct error identifying the endpoint and the observed size, rather than letting the reconnect path replay the payload.
• Failing that, a documented hook to inspect a raw message before parsing would let clients implement this without patching private methods.
• Independently: _handle_sse_event returning False for a parse failure causes the caller to treat the stream as ended and reconnect with Last-Event-ID; for a deterministic failure (such as a payload that will always be too large, or malformed JSON) this retries something that cannot succeed.

Happy to open a PR if a maintainer indicates the preferred shape (constructor arg vs. env var vs. pre-parse hook).

Inizia in mcp/client/streamable_http.py, nel punto di analisi SSE intorno alla riga 217, e ispeziona _handle_sse_event e _handle_json_response per entrambi i percorsi in ingresso. Poi leggi BaseSession._receive_loop e _handle_incoming per comprendere la gestione dei fallimenti delle richieste in sospeso. Il lavoro è completato quando i messaggi troppo grandi vengono rifiutati prima di model_validate_json, la richiesta corrispondente fallisce con un errore utile e la riconnessione non riproduce nuovamente il payload.