mapbox / mapbox/MapboxGeocoder.swift
focalLocation not returning expected results
Nobody has claimed this yet.
- Dominant language
- Swift
- Stars
- 133
- Forks
- 46
- PR merge metrics
- No merged PRs in 30d
Description
Using the example code, plus adding a bit to show placemarks returned from ForwardGeocodeOptions, I came up with this testing code:
func mapView(_ mapView: MGLMapView, regionDidChangeAnimated animated: Bool) {
geocodingDataTask?.cancel()
self.outputText.text = ""
// Variables.userLat and Variables.userLng are set through locationManager
let options = ReverseGeocodeOptions(coordinate: CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: Variables.userLat, longitude: Variables.userLng))
geocodingDataTask = geocoder.geocode(options) { [unowned self] (placemarks, attribution, error) in
if let error = error {
NSLog("%@", error)
} else if let placemarks = placemarks, !placemarks.isEmpty {
self.resultsLabel.text = placemarks[0].qualifiedName
let foptions = ForwardGeocodeOptions(query: self.inputText.text!)
// To refine the search, you can set various properties on the options object.
foptions.allowedISOCountryCodes = ["US"]
foptions.focalLocation = CLLocation(latitude: Variables.userLat, longitude: Variables.userLng)
let neLat = Variables.userLat + 1.0
let neLng = Variables.userLng + 1.0
foptions.allowedRegion?.northEast = CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: neLat, longitude: neLng)
let swLat = Variables.userLat - 1.0
let swLng = Variables.userLng - 1.0
foptions.allowedRegion?.southWest = CLLocationCoordinate2D(latitude: swLat, longitude: swLng)
foptions.allowedScopes = [.address, .pointOfInterest]
let _ = geocoder.geocode(foptions) { (placemarks, attribution, error) in
guard let placemark = placemarks?.first else {
return
}
let coordinate = placemark.location.coordinate
print("\(coordinate.latitude), \(coordinate.longitude)")
self.inputLat.text = coordinate.latitude.description
self.inputLng.text = coordinate.longitude.description
var string = ""
for mark in placemarks! {
if string != "" {
string += "\n"
}
string += mark.qualifiedName
}
self.outputText.text = string
}
} else {
self.resultsLabel.text = "No results"
}
}
}
That gives me a mini-app to test out the data that is returned when I change locations in the Xcode Simulator.

As you can see from this shot, I have centered the map in Jenks, OK (a small town just outside of Tulsa, OK - sort of a 'central US' location.)
When searching for a common place in that area ("Walmart" - which is based in nearby Arkansas, so there are plenty of them around), you can see that only 2 'local' Walmart's come back in the search.
Now, let's move to Bentonville, AR - the home of Walmart......

And, we get two top new results, but the others are the same (and much farther away than Tulsa, OK.....)
We found that if we add the town to the first of the search, the results are much better:

(similar results are true for every search we did - various cities around the US and with other 'common places' like Quiznos (similar results as Walmart when in their home town of Denver, CO...)
As you can see from my code, I tried using the allowedRegion?.northEast and southWest (as I understand it, those should set the search area to about 100 miles around the location, though I'm not sure I set that up right), though no difference was found from this setup (i.e., with/without I get the same results).
The only 'better' results were by putting in the town name along with the 'common' one (though, oddly, different results were returned if the town name was before or after the common one - I didn't check exactly, though I think they are 'best' (i.e., locations are all pretty near) from putting the town name after the common one)
What can I do to get better results without having to tell the user to enter the town name (not a very desirable plan! :)
Thank you in advance for tips - the lookup is a part of my first app (not the test stuff shown in the pictures! ) and one of the key features the users expect is to pull up 'nearby' common places, so it is an important thing for us that this work much more reliably than we are seeing now.
Contributor guide
First steps
- Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
- Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
- Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
- Open a pull request that references the issue number.
Research direction
Start with the ForwardGeocodeOptions example in the issue and reproduce the Walmart searches while changing focalLocation and allowedRegion. Compare the returned placemarks for Jenks, Bentonville, and the other described locations; done would require determining whether the observed ranking or search-area behavior is a bug and identifying a concrete change.
Written by the indexing model from the issue text.
Assessment
- Tech stack
- ios, swift
- Domain
- mobile-dev, search
- Issue type
- Bug
- Difficulty
- 5/5
- Estimated time
- Over a week
- Activity status
- Stale
- Clarity
- Needs clarification
- Newbie friendliness
- 25/100