github / github/gh-stack

link doesn't recognize a branch's existing merged/closed PR, tries to create a duplicate

Ouverte
#373 0 commentaires 1 réaction 0 personnes assignées Voir sur GitHub
bug topic: cli - link
Langage dominant
Go
Étoiles
1.5k
Forks
70
Merge moyen
1 j 8 h
PR mergées (30 j)
7

Description

## Summary

`gh stack link` looks up an existing PR for each branch argument, but the lookup appears scoped to **open** PRs only. For a branch whose PR already merged or was closed (unmerged), `link` reports no PR found and attempts to **create a new one** — contradicting the documented additive-only design ("existing PRs are never removed").

## Repro

1. Build a stack `main <- a <- b <- c <- d <- e` via `gh stack link`.
2. Merge `a` and `b`. Close `c` without merging (its content landed elsewhere, or it was abandoned).
3. Later, run `gh stack link` again with the full historical branch list (e.g. to fix `d`'s base after `c` closed):
`gh stack link a b c d e --base main`

## Actual

```
Checking existing stacks...
Pushing N branches to origin...
Looking up PRs for 5 branches...
Found PR #.. for branch d
Found PR #.. for branch e
Creating 3 PRs...
✗ failed to create PR for branch a: creating PR: GraphQL: was submitted too quickly, Head sha can't be blank, Base sha can't be blank, No commits between main and a, Head ref must be a branch (createPullRequest)
```

Only the still-open branches (`d`, `e`) were recognized as "Found PR". The merged branch `a` (whose content is already in `main`, hence "No commits between main and a") and the closed branch `c` were both treated as PR-less and queued for creation.

In my case the create call failed immediately on the first attempt (an already-merged branch has no diff vs. its base, so `createPullRequest` rejects it), so no duplicate PR was actually created — I confirmed this via `gh pr list --head --state all` for each affected branch afterward. But this looks like it depends on the specific branch/repo state; a branch that still has *some* diff against the base (e.g. a closed-but-unmerged PR whose branch wasn't cleaned up) would likely succeed in creating a genuine duplicate PR.

## Expected

`link`'s PR lookup should match a branch's PR regardless of state (open, closed, or merged) before deciding whether to create a new one, consistent with the "existing PRs are never removed" behavior documented for this command.

## Environment

`gh-stack` version 0.0.8, installed via `gh extension install github/gh-stack`.

Related: #372 (same investigation session, different symptom of the same overall stack-mutation scenario — see also the atomicity issue I'm filing separately).

Guide de contribution

Ouvrir le guide de contribution

Piste de recherche

Commencez au point d’entrée `gh stack link` et suivez la recherche des PR existantes avant l’appel à `createPullRequest`. Reproduisez le problème avec des branches fusionnées et fermées, puis comparez avec `gh pr list --head --state all`. C’est terminé lorsque les PR existantes dans n’importe quel état sont reconnues et qu’aucune création en double n’est tentée.

Rédigé par le modèle d'indexation à partir du texte de l'issue.

Évaluation

Stack technique
github, go
Domaine
api, cli
Type d'issue
Bug
Difficulté
3/5
Temps estimé
1-2 jours
Activité
Calme
Clarté
Plutôt claire
Accessibilité débutants
66/100

Recevez les nouvelles issues par e-mail

Un résumé court des issues GitHub adaptées aux débutants.