Assignability to a Protocol Using `Self` Must Respect Variance

I just stumbled across this paragraph:

https://github.com/python/typing/blob/2d88da2a407b556f5b52b4c6ad1bd659873bb9ac/docs/spec/generics.rst?plain=1#L2540-L2544

If I understand it correctly, then the following code is fine, i.e., Foo is assignable to Proto according to the explanation:

from __future__ import annotations

from typing import Protocol, Self


class Proto(Protocol):
    def f(self, x: Self) -> None: ...


class Foo:
    def f(self, x: Sub) -> None:
        pass


class Sub(Foo):
    pass


x: Proto = Foo()

However, type checkers like mypy and pyright reject this code. This aligns with my expectation: If I have an instance x: Proto, then I should be able to call x.f(x). But for y: Foo, I cannot call y.f(y).

The paragraph in question should distinguish between covariant, contravariant, and invariant occurences of Self:

from __future__ import annotations

from typing import Protocol, Self


class Proto(Protocol):
    def f(self, x: Self) -> None: ...  # contravariant
    def g(self, x: Self) -> Self: ...  # x: contravariant, return type: covariant
    def h(self, x: list[Self]) -> None: ...  # invariant


class Sup:
    pass


class Foo(Sup):
    def f(self, x: Sup) -> None:  # x can be of type Foo or any superclass
        pass

    def g(self, x: Sup) -> Sub:  # return type can be Foo or any subclass
        raise RuntimeError()

    def h(self, x: list[Foo]) -> None:  # no sub-/superclass allowed as argument to list
        pass


class Sub(Foo):
    pass


x: Proto = Foo()  # OK, also according to mypy and pyright

I assume that all the uses of Self are valid in this example, at least mypy and pyright do not complain and I couldn’t find any statement that would restrict Self in protocols to covariant positions or even return types only. Maybe it also makes sense to adjust the example after the paragraph in question. Currently, it only uses Self in a return type.

Comienza con docs/spec/generics.rst en las líneas enlazadas 2540-2544 y revisa la discusión circundante sobre Self en los protocolos. Ejecuta los ejemplos proporcionados con mypy y pyright, y después actualiza el párrafo y el ejemplo cercano para explicar los usos contravariantes, covariantes e invariantes de Self; se considerará terminado cuando la especificación coincida con el comportamiento demostrado por los analizadores.