Feature Request: Expose Handling Frame Information in Python's Traceback Module

Feature or enhancement

Proposal:

Problem: When dealing with chained exceptions in Python, there is no straightforward way to identify the "outermost handling frame": the frame in the except/finally block that starts the part of the stacktrace that's unique to the "during the handling" exception.

This information is not visible in the textual stacktrace, nor is it accessible programmatically via Python's traceback module (or similar tools).

Since this "handling frame" represents half of the link between 2 exceptions when shown in "chained mode", the fact that this information is missing makes it very hard to see how 2 chained exceptions actually relate to each other.

Proposal: Extend Python's traceback-related modules (e.g., traceback, sys.exc_info) to expose handling frame information. This would allow developers and tools to programmatically determine where exceptions are caught and re-raised in the call stack.

(It would seem to me that just changing the underlying datastructures leads to the least disruption in peoples' workflow, while still allowing for some users to extract the information if they need it)

Current Behavior:

Using the following example:

class OriginalException(Exception):
    pass

class AnotherException(Exception):
    pass

def raise_another_exception():
    raise AnotherException()

def show_something():
    try:
        raise OriginalException()
    except OriginalException:
        raise_another_exception()

show_something()

Running this code produces:

Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "example.py", line 15, in show_something
    raise OriginalException()
__main__.OriginalException

During handling of the above exception, another exception occurred:

Traceback (most recent call last):
  File "example.py", line 20, in <module>
    show_something()
  File "example.py", line 17, in show_something
    raise_another_exception()
  File "example.py", line 10, in raise_another_exception
    raise AnotherException()
__main__.AnotherException

In this traceback, line 17 (raise_another_exception()) is the handling frame, but there is no direct way to programmatically extract this information.

Proposed Improvement:

Enhance the traceback-related API(s) to expose handling frame information.

Has this already been discussed elsewhere?

This is a minor feature, which does not need previous discussion elsewhere

Links to previous discussion of this feature:

I wrote extensively about this problem (as well as more generally about how confusing chained stacktraces can be) on my blog.

This is obviously not actually a discussion since it doesn't involve other people, but I do think it's useful context (and it's better to keep the longer story out of the feature-request)

Linked PRs

• gh-127021

Commencez par lire les API liées à traceback et sys.exc_info, en utilisant l’exemple show_something et raise_another_exception comme comportement à comprendre. Consultez le PR lié gh-127021 pour examiner le travail existant. Le travail est terminé lorsque l’API liée à traceback expose le frame de gestion des exceptions chaînées d’une manière définie et utilisable.