os.path.normpath of relative path r".\C:\x" returns absolute path r"C:\x" on Windows, similar in pathlib

os.path.normpath normalizes "./" or "../" path elements to clean the path.

As os.path.normpath doesn't consider a case where the normalized path starts with a drive letter, a relative path with a drive letter-like path element will be normalized to an absolute path. This behavior can result in a path traversal, depending on the implementation.

The minimal snippet to reproduce this behavior is the following:

> os.path.normpath("./C:/Windows/System32")

This snippet will return "C:\Windows\System32", which is an absolute path on Windows. (tested with Python 3.11.1 on Windows)

This vulnerability is similar to CVE-2022-29804 of Go.

as reported to security@ by RyotaK on 2022-12-09.

Golang solved their issue in https://github.com/golang/go/issues/52476 which may be helpful to look at.

The Python Security Response Team agreed that this issue did not require an embargo.

It looks like pathlib probably also has issues in this area:

>>> p1 = pathlib.PureWindowsPath('P:\\windows')
>>> p2 = pathlib.PureWindowsPath('.\\P:\\windows')
>>> p1 == p2
False
>>> p1
PureWindowsPath('P:/windows')
>>> p2
PureWindowsPath('P:/windows')
>>> p1.is_absolute()
True
>>> p2.is_absolute()
False
>>> str(p1) == str(p2)
True

Comienza con el comportamiento de os.path.normpath mostrado en la reproducción de Windows y, a continuación, inspecciona los ejemplos relacionados de pathlib.PureWindowsPath. Compara cómo se clasifican y normalizan las rutas relativas que contienen elementos similares a letras de unidad, y utiliza los fragmentos para verificar que las rutas relativas siguen siendo relativas, mientras que las rutas absolutas conservan su comportamiento existente.