PDO::FETCH_COLUMN | PDO::FETCH_GROUP with column parameter behavior

Description

I believe the current code behavior of FETCH_COLUMN | FETCH_GROUP when specifying the column parameter is non-sensical. I believe it was not originally designed to work this way.

(And does not match the current documentation ... but that seems to be part of the story to how it got broken - see timeline below)

To see what I'm talking about, please refer to https://github.com/AllenJB/sandbox/blob/main/php-docs/pdo/fetch-modes/column/group.phpt (3v4l version: https://3v4l.org/2f7aV )

When you use FETCH_COLUMN, you can specify the additional column parameter to fetchAll() to tell PDO which column to retrieve values from. However, when you combine it with FETCH_GROUP, the column number is used for the grouping key and the values returned are always the first column.

This does not match my personal expected behavior, especially given that the column parameter can only be used with the COLUMN fetch mode - no other fetch mode allows you to influence how GROUP works in this way.

It also does not match the current documentation for PDOStatement::fetchAll()

You can see from the 3v4l link above that COLUMN | GROUP works as I expected in PHP <5.2.6.

I could find no tests in php-src for the combination of COLUMN | GROUP and specifying the column parameter.

The following is a timeline I put together for this:

2005-08-31: PDOStatement::fetchAll docs updated to include FETCH_GROUP, but the behavior described does not match the then actual behavior
2008-05-01: PHP 5.2.6 changes the behavior to somewhat match the docs (I believe the bug that triggered this is https://bugs.php.net/bug.php?id=44362 ) (if you read it one way, but this just ends up confusing because if you read it this way to column parameter has 2 different purposes at the same time)
2024-10-06: PDOStatement::fetchAll docs changed to describe the original < 5.2.6 behavior

PHP Version

8.4.13

Operating System

n/a

Beginne mit der Reproduktion in php-docs/pdo/fetch-modes/column/group.phpt und vergleiche deren Ausgabe mit dem 3v4l-Beispiel. Lies die Dokumentation zu PDOStatement::fetchAll() und untersuche die PDO-Fetch-Implementierung sowie die bestehenden Tests für FETCH_COLUMN und FETCH_GROUP. Die Aufgabe ist abgeschlossen, wenn das beabsichtigte Verhalten von Spalten und Gruppierung vereinbart, durch einen Regressionstest abgedeckt und konsistent dokumentiert ist.