`"packageManager"` field doesn’t support npm

Version

21.6.2

Platform

Linux a3bc0d85e2cf 6.6.12-linuxkit #1 SMP Thu Feb 8 06:36:34 UTC 2024 aarch64 GNU/Linux

Subsystem

Corepack

What steps will reproduce the bug?

docker pull node:latest
docker run -it --entrypoint bash node
mkdir app && cd app
npm init -y
node --eval 'const fs = require("fs"); const pjson = JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync("./package.json", "utf8")); pjson.packageManager = "npm@9"; fs.writeFileSync("./package.json", JSON.stringify(pjson, null, 2));'
npm install

How often does it reproduce? Is there a required condition?

Always.

What is the expected behavior? Why is that the expected behavior?

I should get an error that my current version of npm (10.2.4) doesn’t match the version defined in the packageManager field (9).

What do you see instead?

npm 10 runs without complaint.

Additional information

I understand that npm isn’t a “supported package manager” per https://nodejs.org/api/corepack.html#supported-package-managers, which is linked from https://nodejs.org/api/packages.html#packagemanager; but npm is distributed with Node, so it should be a supported package manager. It is a bad user experience to ship two tools (npm and Corepack) that don’t work together.

Furthermore, I don’t want my version of npm to need to be pinned; I want to be able to specify a minimum, like “npm 10+” but not a maximum; or to be able to say npm@* to enforce that this project requires npm but no particular version. I don’t want the packageManager field to cause me to use a version of npm that may have security vulnerabilities that have been patched in a newer version of npm. The maintainers of npm recommend always using the latest npm version, and it feels wrong (and a poor security practice) for the packageManager field to contradict this.

@nodejs/corepack @nodejs/loaders @nodejs/npm @nodejs/package-maintenance

Beginne damit, die Docker-Reproduktion auszuführen, und prüfe Corepacks Behandlung von packageManager zusammen mit der im Issue verlinkten Dokumentation zu supported-package-managers und packages. Vergleiche das beobachtete npm-Verhalten mit den angeforderten Erwartungen an version-mismatch und version-range; abgeschlossen ist die Aufgabe, wenn die vorgesehene npm-Unterstützung und die Versionsrichtlinie klar definiert und getestet sind.