Don't allow math operations on different branded numeric types

🔎 Search Terms

number numeric branded types plus minus add subtract

🕗 Version & Regression Information

• This is the behavior in every version I tried, and I reviewed the FAQ for entries about Nominal types (tagged, branded)

⏯ Playground Link

https://www.typescriptlang.org/play/?#code/C4TwDgpgBAwgrgJwRAdgYxAHgCoD4oC8UKcAtgEYQJQBkUA3lAPpNqLLogBcU2UAvgG4AUKEhQAoogD2hWO1QZMAIggzluEWOgBVAMoAROfCSKsyuAGcAJhpHCAZnHTAAltJRQ0AQxQAFRDQAC29LCABJYAhSAAowBFc0CJQpBGkeVOkAGigAd28AGwKIYHCUfQMeCoBKBmEoBqgAeiaoADlZbSgqNIQc8jhgKHC86TgC6ygQgDdoCAAPSDQoyY8IesbkYERPfKKSsoqofHjE5MyRfmEgA

💻 Code

type Currency<T> = number & { __currency: T };
type Euro = Currency<"euro">;
type USD = Currency<"usd">;

function canPurchaseItem(priceInEuro: Euro, walletInUSD: USD) {
    // No type error, but I would have expected one
    return walletInUSD > priceInEuro;
}

🙁 Actual behavior

Euro and USD -two different branded numeric types- can be compared with binary operators such as -.

🙂 Expected behavior

These are two different branded numeric types. I would have expected that binary operations between the two of them would be disallowed.

More technically, if a mathematical binary operation contains:

• one value that is an intersection of number and some object type
• another value that is not assignable to that type

...then I'd expect to receive a type error.

Additional information about the issue

Per #202, TypeScript doesn't actually formally include a built-in branded/nominal typing. But other mismatched operators are disallowed [playground of mismatched operators]:

// These are all type errors:
console.log([] + []);
console.log([] + {});
console.log([] + 1);
console.log({} + 1);
console.log({} + {});
console.log({ a: 1 } + { b: 2 });

Beginne mit dem bereitgestellten Playground-Beispiel und vergleiche es mit dem verlinkten mismatched-operator-Beispiel, um das aktuelle Prüfverhalten zu verstehen. Die Arbeit ist abgeschlossen, wenn Operationen zwischen unterschiedlichen gebrandeten numerischen Schnittmengen die erwarteten Typfehler erzeugen, ohne die bestehenden mismatched-operator-Fehler zu verschlechtern.