Isolated declarations does not handle object getters and setters with different types

🔎 Search Terms

• isolated declarations
• object getter
• object setter

🕗 Version & Regression Information

5.5.0-dev.20240514

⏯ Playground Link

https://www.typescriptlang.org/play/?target=99&isolatedDeclarations=true&ts=5.5.0-dev.20240514#code/KYDwDg9gTgLgBAYwgOwM7wIZwLxwN4BQcxcA5sPAEYAUAlAFxzpQCWyp+RJ3UFArlGRwARMK7EAvgBpxTCnBoA3DABtGzNqVqduEghIDcBAjACeYYHADKMVuwCCKlhlQ4mtzUdCRYiFOkQ3Qm5yeAATOkYbO1JHZ1dg7hJeGAEhUVlpWVR5COU1dxjtRMl9I2NvaHgkNHhLXBKyeQAzSMLNHSTiFLSRMV0Zbhz4VvzGZD4AW0pgKGLMsqA

💻 Code

export const a = {
    get b(): string {
        return ""
    },
    set b(val: string) {
    }
};

type StringAlias = string;
export const c = {
    get d(): StringAlias {
        return ""
    },
    set d(val: string) {
    }
};


export const e = {
    get f(): string {
        return ""
    },
    set f(val: number) {
    }
};

🙁 Actual behavior

TypeScript emits:

export declare const a: {
    b: string;
};
export declare const c: {
    d: string;
};
export declare const e: {
    get f(): string;
    set f(val: number);
};

This is behaviour is not possible to reproduce for isolated declarations emitters, because it requires type comparisons for the types of the setter and getter.

🙂 Expected behavior

One of:

Emit based on syntax, do not collapse a getter/setter pair with the same type to a property

export declare const a: {
    get b(): string;
    set b(val: string);
};
export declare const c: {
    get d(): StringAlias;
    set d(val: string);
};
export declare const e: {
    get f(): string;
    set f(val: number);
};

OR

Error on both c.d and e.f because return type of getter and setter do not match

Additional information about the issue

cc @dragomirtitian

Comienza con el ejemplo de Playground proporcionado usando isolatedDeclarations y compara las declaraciones emitidas para a, c y e. El issue no menciona archivos ni pruebas del repositorio; primero habría que decidir entre la emisión de getters/setters basada en la sintaxis y los errores para tipos que no coinciden, y después verificar de forma coherente el comportamiento elegido.