Remote MCP: transient 5xx (e.g. 502) on `initialize` marks server failed for the whole session with no retry/backoff
Personne n'a encore pris cette issue.
- Langage dominant
- Shell
- Étoiles
- 11.2k
- Forks
- 1.9k
- Merge moyen
- 14 h 16 min
- PR mergées (30 j)
- 6
Description
Describe the bug
When a remote (type: http) MCP server returns a transient HTTP 5xx (observed: 502 Bad Gateway) on the initialize request at session startup, the CLI records a hard, per-session failure for that server and never retries it for the remaining lifetime of the session. The server then shows as unavailable for the whole run, even though the endpoint recovers seconds later.
This is especially damaging for headless / autopilot workflow (automation) sessions, which cold-start a fresh MCP client on every run: a single unlucky 502 at startup silently disables a required connector for that entire run, with no self-heal. A long-lived interactive session that already completed initialize is unaffected, which makes the failure look inconsistent ("it's green in the app but unavailable in automation").
Observed log (one automation run; server names generic):
[ERROR] rmcp::transport::worker: worker quit with fatal:
UnexpectedServerResponse("HTTP 502 Bad Gateway")
[DEBUG] native_host: Recorded failure for server <Remote Server>: failed to initialize MCP client …
[ERROR] Failed to start MCP client for <Remote Server>: … unexpected server response:
HTTP 502 Bad Gateway, when send initialize request
The endpoint returned a normal 401 auth challenge (healthy) on direct probes seconds later — i.e. the 502 was transient/cold-start, not a real outage.
Affected version
1.0.79-9 (bundled SDK; buildMetadata.gitCommit 65f2c0f). Windows x64. Logic lives in the Rust MCP transport / native_host, so expected to be platform-independent.
Steps to reproduce the behavior
- Configure a
type: httpremote MCP server whose upstream occasionally returns a transient5xxoninitialize(e.g. a scale-to-zero / cold-start backend behind a gateway). - Start a session (or let a scheduled/autopilot workflow run) so the CLI cold-starts the MCP client and sends
initialize. - When
initializehappens to hit the transient502, observe:Recorded failure for server <name>andFailed to start MCP client for <name> … HTTP 502 Bad Gateway.- The server stays unavailable for the entire session — no retry, no backoff, no re-
initialize.
- Probe the same endpoint directly a few seconds later → it responds normally (e.g.
401auth challenge), confirming the 5xx was transient.
Expected behavior
Transient 5xx responses during MCP initialize should be retried with bounded exponential backoff (a few attempts over several seconds) before the server is marked failed. Ideally also allow a later lazy re-initialize/reconnect within the session rather than latching "failed" for the whole run. Distinguish transient transport/gateway 5xx (retryable) from 401/OAuth challenges (handled by the auth flow) and from 4xx config errors (not retryable).
Additional context
- Impact is amplified for scheduled/autopilot automation sessions: they re-cold-start MCP clients every run, so a single startup 502 disables a required connector for that run with no recovery, producing intermittent "connector unavailable" failures that are hard to diagnose.
- A long-lived interactive session that already completed
initializekeeps working, so the same server can appear "connected (green)" in the interactive UI while every fresh automation session reports it unavailable. - Suggested scope: retry policy on the
initializesend path in the streamable-http MCP client worker; treat5xx/transport-closed as retryable with capped attempts + jittered backoff. - Related: the OAuth silent-refresh scope bug tracked in #4464 (a separate failure mode on the same class of remote servers). This retry issue is independent — it fires before auth, on the transport layer.
- OS: Windows x64.
Guide de contribution
Ouvrir le guide de contribution
Par où commencer
- Lisez l'issue en entier, puis le guide de contribution du projet.
- Signalez en commentaire que vous la prenez — cela évite que deux personnes fassent le même travail.
- Forkez le dépôt et travaillez sur une branche.
- Ouvrez une pull request qui référence le numéro de l'issue.
Piste de recherche
Commencez par suivre le chemin d’envoi de initialize du worker client MCP streamable-http dans le transport MCP Rust ainsi que l’enregistrement des échecs de native_host. Reproduisez un 502 transitoire, puis vérifiez les nouvelles tentatives limitées avec backoff, tout en conservant le traitement actuel des challenges 401/OAuth et des réponses 4xx non réessayables. C’est terminé lorsqu’un endpoint rétabli peut s’initialiser au cours de la même session au lieu de rester marqué comme ayant échoué.
Rédigé par le modèle d'indexation à partir du texte de l'issue.
Évaluation
- Stack technique
- rust
- Domaine
- networking
- Type d'issue
- Bug
- Difficulté
- 4/5
- Temps estimé
- 3-5 jours
- Activité
- Calme
- Clarté
- Plutôt claire
- Accessibilité débutants
- 52/100