angular / angular/angular-cli

Dynamic base href (APP_BASE_HREF) for SSR

Open
#29,449 6 comments 11 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
area: @angular/ssr feature feature: insufficient votes
Dominant language
TypeScript
Stars
27k
Forks
11.8k
Avg merge
14h 23m
Merged PRs (30d)
162

Description

### Which @angular/* package(s) are relevant/related to the feature request?

_No response_

### Description

I'm using Angular as SSR multi tenant app.

We differentiate the clients per domain.

exemple:
potato.com/portal
tomato.com/citizen
onion-tickets.com

The majority from our clients use a specific base href and just a few serve the app on the root.

Right now it's difficult to work with angular with this setup, I had to do some 'stuff' on the SSR server to make it work.

We use a similar configuration for development too because it's easy to use domains rather than keep changing the client for localhost. This also allows to have many clients configured at the same time.

For the development we simply add on the OS hosts file `[CLIENT].local` and have nginx running on docker.
This has sped up a lot of developing time.

We are migrating from angular 16 to 19 and already preparing for the `AngularNodeAppEngine` because from what I saw in the docs it will be the default instead of the `ngExpressEngine` and `CommonEngine`.

At the moment there are (what I believe is regression) some things that worked in v16 that don't work in v19, and it impacts production and development.

I was preparing a repo with an example app to list those problems, but later realized that if the APP_BASE_HREF doesn't work like before, none of the other stuff matters.

This is part of the code that we use to make it work.

```typescript
// this will garantee that all the js are served from the right routes.
if (condition) {
res.render(indexHtml, {
req,
document: docWithoutBaseHref
});
} else {
res.render(indexHtml, {
req,
providers: [{ provide: APP_BASE_HREF, useValue: clientBaseHref }],
document: docWithBaseHref
})
}
```

As you can see by the name of the variables `docWithoutBaseHref` and `docWithBaseHref` we also manually parse the index file to add and remove the base href according to the domain and base href from the request.

I look it up in the code for v19 and the base href is retrieved from the html generated on the bundling process by the `.handle(req)` method from `AngularNodeAppEngine`, this break our app because we need to put the base href that came from the SSR request, instead of reading from a static file.

Is there a possibility to have this again working with Angular?

We tested with `commonEngine` and it has the same capabilities from `ngExpressEngine`.

The problem is that I don't think the angular team will maintain multiple packages, considering that the Server routes it's supported only by `AngularNodeAppEngine` and it will be the future of angular SSR and the other options will be deprecated.

We would like to know if something like this will be considered to be supported by `AngularNodeAppEngine`?

We can still keep using the packages/code that allow our customization, but this will only delay the problem and will force us to stay attached to an older version of angular. And prevent the use of new features.

We rely on this information to make a decision about how to move forward.

Thanks.
Cheers.

### Proposed solution

Allow for customization of html files from the SSR server instead of using hard coded values.
Allow to provide dynamic base href from SSR to the rendering of an angular route.

### Alternatives considered

Keep using an older angular version and never upgrade.
Move to another framework.

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

Research direction

Start by reading AngularNodeAppEngine.handle and compare its base-href handling with the existing CommonEngine and ngExpressEngine behavior. Trace how APP_BASE_HREF and the request reach SSR rendering, then define what support for a request-specific base href would require. Done means the SSR output can use the base href supplied by the request without manually parsing the index file.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Assessment

Tech stack
angular, typescript
Domain
backend, web-dev
Issue type
Feature
Difficulty
5/5
Estimated time
Over a week
Activity status
Stale
Clarity
Mostly clear
Newbie friendliness
35/100

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.