adobe-fonts / adobe-fonts/source-han-sans

Contour connection issue in glyphs with component 丂, 及, 乃, and 弓

Open
#512 2 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
fixed for next version
Dominant language
Python
Stars
17.2k
Forks
1.4k
PR merge metrics
No merged PRs in 30d

Description

Wow, seems it's quite easy for the slanted L shape to miss the connection. Makes me wonder if it's better to try catching these issues by code. I suspect many of them should have been fixed, but I'm posting it here first.

Issue example:
![image](https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/c75a70a9-7a80-451b-94b0-c8278e7473c4)

### A. With component 及
| # | Glyph name | Character | Master |
| -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 1 | uni5C8C-CN | 岌 | H
| 2 | uni3F7A-CN | 㽺 | H
| 3 | uni5C8B-HK % | 岋 | EL, H
| 4 | uni89D9-HK % | 觙 | EL, H

% In these 2 codepoints the upper ⺂ (slanted ┐) follow JP/TW design in the and seems the designer had a hard time to maintain the angle with the lower 𠃌 component. Suggest to replace it with the CN/HK design for consistency.

### B. With component 乃
| # | Glyph name | Character | Master |
| -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 1 | uni347A-CN | 㑺 | EL, H
| 2 | uni36E2-CN | 㛢 | EL
| 3 | uni36E2-HK | 㛢 | EL
| 4 | uni3A57-CN | 㩗 | H
| 5 | uni3EB1-CN | 㺱 | H
| 6 | uni42FC-CN | 䋼 | EL, H
| 7 | uni46AE-CN | 䚮 | EL, H (EL also missed the connection with 𠃌)
| 8 | uni643A-CN | 携 | EL, H
| 9 | uni6736-CN | 朶 | EL
| 10 | uni6979-CN | 楹 | EL, H
| 11 | uni6E8B-CN | 溋 | EL, H
| 12 | uni7407-CN | 琇 | EL
| 13 | uni7407-TW | 琇 | EL
| 14 | uni7D89-CN | 綉 | EL
| 15 | uni7D89-HK | 綉 | EL
| 16 | uni8A98-CN | 誘 | EL
| 17 | uni92B9-HK | 銹 | EL
| 18 | uni93B8-CN | 鎸 | EL, H

### C. With component 弓, including 弓, 夷, 弗, 弱.
| # | Glyph name | Character | Master |
| -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 1 | uni4F87-CN | 侇 | EL
| 2 | uni54A6-CN | 咦 | EL
| 3 | uni59E8-CN | 姨 | EL
| 4 | uni59E8-TW | 姨 | EL
| 5 | uni5CD3-CN | 峓 | EL
| 6 | uni5CD3-TW | 峓 | EL
| 7 | uni5F29-CN | 弩 | EL
| 8 | uni5F2E-CN | 弮 | H
| 9 | uni5F3A-CN | 强 | EL
| 10 | uni605E-CN | 恞 | EL
| 11 | uni684B-CN | 桋 | EL
| 12 | uni6AE0-CN | 櫠 | EL, H
| 13 | uni6D1F-CN | 洟 | EL
| 14 | uni7731-CN | 眱 | EL
| 15 | uni7A79-CN | 穹 | H
| 16 | uni7AAE-CN | 窮 | EL
| 17 | uni7AAE-TW | 窮 | EL
| 18 | uni7CA5-CN | 粥 | EL (The right one)
| 19 | uni7CA5-TW | 粥 | EL (The right one)
| 20 | uni7CE8-CN | 糨 | H
| 21 | uni7FA0-CN | 羠 | EL
| 22 | uni80F0-CN | 胰 | EL
| 23 | uni80F0-TW | 胰 | EL
| 24 | uni845E-CN | 葞 | H
| 25 | uni845E-TW | 葞 | H
| 26 | uni85ED-CN | 藭 | EL (弓 is fine but the vertical stroke in "┌" of 身 is too long)
| 27 | uni86E6-CN | 蛦 | EL
| 28 | uni8941-CN | 蛦 | H (connection in 𠃌)
| 29 | uni8B3D-TW | 謽 | H (connection in the 2 horizontal strokes)
| 30 | uni8DE0-CN | 跠 | EL
| 31 | uni9710-CN | 霐 | H
| 32 | uni9710-TW | 霐 | H
| 33 | uni971B-CN | 霛 | H (all 3 弓s)
| 34 | uni971B-HK | 霛 | H (all 3 弓s)
| 35 | uni9C2F-CN | 鰯 | EL (all 2 弓s)
| 36 | uni9C2F-HK | 鰯 | EL (all 2 弓s)

### D. With component 丂

| # | Glyph | Character | Master |
|--------|-----------|-----------|-------------|
| 1 | uni357A-CN | 㕺 | EL
| 2 | uni3671-CN | 㙱 | H
| 3 | uni3841-CN | 㡁 | EL
| 4 | uni390D-CN | 㤍 | H
| 5 | uni3B3D-CN | 㬽 | EL
| 6 | uni3C15-CN | 㰕 | H
| 7 | uni3F25-CN | ~~㛈~~ 㼥 | H
| 8 | uni3FFD-CN | 㿽 | EL, H
| 9 | uni4080-CN | 䂀 | H
| 10 | uni4522-CN | 䔢 | H
| 11 | uni46B7-CN | 䚷 | EL
| 12 | uni4ABD-CN | 䪽 | H
| 13 | uni4CBE-CN | 䲾 | EL, H
| 14 | uni4CD9-CN | 䳙 | H
| 15 | uni4E8F-CN | 丂 | EL
| 16 | uni53F7-CN | 号 | EL
| 17 | uni547A-CN | 呺 | H
| 18 | uni5938-CN | 夸 | H
| 19 | uni678D-CN | 枍 | EL (also check the 2 curved strokes in radical 木)
| 20 | uni678D-TW | 枍 | EL (also check the 2 curved strokes in radical 木)
| 21 | uni67B5-CN | 枵 | H
| 22 | uni7539-CN | 甹 | H
| 23 | uni76FB-CN | 盻 | EL
| 24 | uni76FB-TW | 盻 | EL
| 25 | uni7CA4-CN | 粤 | EL
| 26 | uni7D5D-CN | 絝 | EL
| 27 | uni7FB2-CN | 羲 | EL (connection in 𠃌)
| 28 | uni8342-CN | 荂 | EL
| 29 | uni8342-TW | 荂 | EL
| 30 | uni8AE1-CN | 諡 | EL
| 31 | uni8AE1-TW | 諡 | EL
| 32 | uni8C14-CN | 谔 | H
| 33 | uni8FC3-CN | 迃 | H
| 34 | uni904C-CN | 遌 | EL, H
| 35 | uni9120-CN | 鄠 | H
| 36 | uni96E9-CN | 雩 | EL
| 37 | uni96E9-TW | 雩 | EL
| 38 | uni9955-CN | 饕 | H
| 39 | uni9955-TW | 饕 | H
| 40 | uni9C10-CN | 鰐 | H

Contributor guide

No contributing guide indexed for this repository

Assessment

This issue has not been assessed yet.

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.