PowerShell / PowerShell/PSScriptAnalyzer

`Invoke-ScriptAnalyzer` `-Severity` filters rules rather than diagnostics

Open
#2,156 1 comment 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub

Nobody has claimed this yet.

Dominant language
C#
Stars
2.2k
Forks
414
Avg merge
13h 1m
Merged PRs (30d)
2

Description

The -Severity parameter of Invoke-ScriptAnalyzer does not do what it says it does.

Parameter help for the -Severity parameter says:

After running Script Analyzer with all rules, this parameter selects rule violations with the specified severity.
...
The parameter filters the rules violations only after running all rules.
...

In reality the parameter filters rules and not diagnostics; both have the concept of Severity (RuleSeverity, and DiagnosticSeverity)


How the -Severity parameter is ultimately used:

  1. The user passes -Severity to Invoke-ScriptAnalyzer. Value validated to be one of "Warning", "Error", "Information", "ParseError".

  2. The ScriptAnalyzer singleton instance is initialised with this -Severity string[] value, which is stored as a private member of the singleton object (severity).

  3. When analyzing a script, the engine determines which rules to run. It uses IsRuleAllowed() to check each rule.

  4. IsRuleAllowed() gets a list of allowedSeverities. It does so by calling GetAllowedSeveritiesInInt().

    Each severity (an array of strings) is parsed into the underlying uint value of the DiagnosticSeverity enum type.

    (I believe this should actually be RuleSeverity enum. It works as both enums have identical members and underlying uint values).
    https://github.com/PowerShell/PSScriptAnalyzer/blob/aba29c31151925bd7180e7dfd578e1bfacdaf2a2/Engine/ScriptAnalyzer.cs#L1929-L1934

  5. IsRuleAllowed() then calls IsSeverityAllowed(allowedSeverities, rule) as part of it's decision making on whether to execute a rule. Passing in the list of allowedSeverities and the current rule being considered.

  6. IsSeverityAllowed(..) then checks if allowedSeverities contains the rules severity (calling rule.GetSeverity() and casting it to a uint). If it does the rule is allowed to run.
    https://github.com/PowerShell/PSScriptAnalyzer/blob/aba29c31151925bd7180e7dfd578e1bfacdaf2a2/Engine/ScriptAnalyzer.cs#L1914-L1921


So there are 2 issues that need to be addressed:

  1. There is a disparity between the documentation and implementation. Either:

    • The documentation needs updating to match reality OR
    • The implementation needs to be updated so -Severity filters the output of DiagnosticRecords.
  2. GetAllowedSeveritiesInInt() resolves severities using DiagnosticSeverity and that is then used to compare to rule.GetSeverity() which is a RuleSeverity. It works now as both enums are identical in their definition and are being cast to their underlying uint value. If either was updated this could break. It also does not seem intentional.

@bergmeister - Should we update the documentation as a first pass and revisit behaviour later if it's desired? I will also get the enum corrected to RuleSeverity.

This explains the issue described in #2049 - where a custom rule is emitting error-level DiagnosticRecord but is not showing with -Severity Error, but is with -Severity Warning. -Severity is filtering the rules that are run (by their severity) and all custom rules have Warning severity.

https://github.com/PowerShell/PSScriptAnalyzer/blob/aba29c31151925bd7180e7dfd578e1bfacdaf2a2/Engine/Generic/ExternalRule.cs#L55-L59

n.b. I have typed the word severity so many times now that it no longer looks like a real word...

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

First steps

  1. Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
  2. Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
  3. Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
  4. Open a pull request that references the issue number.

Research direction

Start with Engine/Commands/InvokeScriptAnalyzerCommand.cs and Engine/ScriptAnalyzer.cs, especially the severity initialization, GetAllowedSeveritiesInInt(), IsSeverityAllowed(), and IsRuleAllowed() entry points. Confirm the intended behavior for filtering rules versus DiagnosticRecords, then ensure the documentation and severity handling consistently reflect that decision.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Assessment

Tech stack
csharp, powershell
Domain
tooling
Issue type
Bug
Difficulty
4/5
Estimated time
3-5 days
Activity status
Quiet
Clarity
Mostly clear
Newbie friendliness
45/100

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.