Incorrect Effective Hit Pool with Evasion and Spell Block

Check version

• I'm running the latest version of Path of Building and I've verified this by checking the changelog

Check for duplicates

• I've checked for duplicate open and closed issues by using the search function of the issue tracker

Check for support

• I've checked that the calculation is supposed to be supported. If it isn't please open a feature request instead (Red text is a feature request).

What platform are you running Path of Building on?

Windows

What is the value from the calculation in-game?

What is the value from the calculation in Path of Building?

The Effective Hit Pool stat is wrong when using the default configuration with Average as Enemy Damage Type in situations where the character has a combination of Evasion and Spell Block Chance.

The current calculation first calculates Mitigated hits using the average block chance, assuming 50% enemy attacks and 50% enemy spells. The enemy miss chance is then applied, again assuming 50-50 attacks and spells, to get the total number of Hits before death. The Hits before death is then multiplied by the total incoming damage to get the Effective Hit Pool.

Given a character with a 75% chance to block spell damage and a 75% chance to evade attacks, the current calculation shows: 62.5% chance for block to fail (75% / 2), so Mitigated hits = Hits before death / 0.625, and 37.5% Enemy miss chance (again 75% / 2), resulting in Hits before death = Mitigated hits / Chance to be hit = (Hits / 0.625) / (1 - 0.375) = Hits / (0.625 * 0.625). However, this is clearly incorrect: 62.5% being 5/8, the current calculation results in 25 out of 64 (0.625 * 0.625 = 39%) hits being unblocked or unevaded, while in reality this should be 16 out of 64 or 25%, as all hits are either attacks or spells.

This incorrect number for Effective Hit Pool is also easily seen by setting the custom modifiers listed below and then changing the Enemy Damage Type in the configuration from Average to any of the typed damage types that it claims to be the average of (Melee, Projectile, Spell, Projectile Spell). The resulting Effective Hit Pool for Average is much lower than any of the specific parts (which are equal except for the effect of Evasion on critical damage).

The correct calculation for Effective Hit Pool should use the expected damage per hit (including block, evasion, projectile avoidance and spell suppression) for each enemy damage type and the expected 25% occurrence of each type: e.g. given 75% spell block, 75% evasion, 1000 life and 100 enemy damage, you expect to live for 40 attempts at damage (20 attacks of which 5 hit and 5 out of 20 spells that are unblocked for a total of 1000 damage), which can be calculated as 1000 / (25% * 25 + 25% * 25 + 25% * 25 + 25% * 25) = 40, as each damage instance has an expected damage taken of 25 after mitigation and evasion.

How to reproduce the issue

Create a new character, paste the following Custom Modifiers in the Configuration:

10000 life
+135 to all resistances
75% chance to block spell damage
75% chance to evade attacks

Change the Enemy Damage Type from Average to each of its parts and observe the Effective Hit Pool number.

PoB for PoE1 build code

https://pobb.in/psSfMgg885HN

Screenshots

The Hits before death of 5.87 should be 2.29 / 0.25 = 9.16 with 75% chance to evade attacks and block spells:

Reproduce el problema en Path of Building con los modificadores personalizados y la build de PoB proporcionados, y luego sigue el cálculo de Effective Hit Pool a partir de la configuración de Enemy Damage Type. Verifica que el promedio use el daño esperado para cada tipo de daño enumerado y que el resultado coincida con los valores introducidos y con el ejemplo indicado de una ocurrencia del 25 %.