PathOfBuildingCommunity / PathOfBuildingCommunity/PathOfBuilding

Wintertide Brand, Elemental Focus, and Bonechill has Strange Interactions + Helmet Chill Enchant not increasing Bonechill Debuff

Open
#2,822 0 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub

Nobody has claimed this yet.

bug
Dominant language
Lua
Stars
5.4k
Forks
2.4k
Avg merge
1d 12h
Merged PRs (30d)
26

Description

If we socket Wintertide Brand - Bonechill - Elemental Focus on a new build and tick the "Enemy is chilled" box in Configuration, and then look at Calcs, we see the following:

With Elemental Focus Disabled:

image

With Elemental Focus Enabled:

image

As you can see, Elemental Focus disables the "Enemies Chilled by Supported Skills have Cold Damage taken increased by Chill Effect" line, but leaves the other line on. The wiki says that Wintertide Brand's chill is not prevented by Elemental Focus, so both lines should be active in both cases. Furthermore, if I add a helmet with the "Wintertide Brand has 40% increased chill effect" enchant, then when Elemental Focus is disabled, it still only shows 14% increased, even though the chill effect should be 18%:

image

So either Wintertide Brand has very strange interactions with Bonechill, or there's an issue here.

Build code:

eNrFW21v2sgW_lx-hYW00r1aJTB-A6NkV4SQFCm0XEjbvZ-qwR5gNoOH2uOkbNX_fs-MzUtSCMdupdtK1MbPeT9z5pwxvfjz61JYjyxJuYwv6-S8WbdYHMqIx_PL-of7m7N2_c8_ahcjqhbvZ1cZF_rJH7U3F-baEuyRCaCrW4omc6Y-bjg5n4HTisZqwWQ8pH_L5FZGl_V3MmZ1a0rjiKvNXShomr6jS3ZZn4RAXLdoGrI46u2-z4FLyuOJDB-Yuk1ktjJiHzl7GsoIMIPh6P34fk8oj_eFgs5vLkaCrlkyUVRZKXxc1rtgOp2zt1wBKyoy4NOsN17FXtMlfJ6GT1aMRVsYOXftttcixef_nwhMfk53FDlKWH82Y6Hij6yXcNVb0DhEOKAsdpgJxVeCs2TPFu8V_V8wJ82j7O-louJ6NDmtSFmk3CWO7XjnjtN0ij_H6D5xtQCyfRklKK8ExAyln0YP5jFXDA0fSZ7KuJT1FczoyeWUx8-tKEnafZyfVvEqgTJzz8OHdIttH8MOaUx7Mt0FkwTHoHd8xp5BjyrQn-BwY6gnOKRWc8QSqI4KR6CVLUUwUbvV5x7XmH3ZBx7FXbOvOG7PgEejNIgVjt0-kHjecfUepTI7DsaPW1TrtZofdjR2EIc4ph_ihKUsedwrxC0kQRFXTP3ThGM2Z0hL7xgLF7ew246pYris3KL8152jsSjnaOAB5_hIghLO0YTPnUPOyWvgku7pxyyZrycLzkSEahvCzj4Jylv7BMhA75OUteiRpvvL5kTMCzgu7Aw2OCCI2Ivd3Q5-IckokX_rhkaUpOsmS5klyCDmYJTVo8U65SFsqKa3HLMoC3F1aduYDeUjW0LCm54OGuJdLh_dHgW00tj-DNgKUYqiqxQNH65lNGelhJSiuOEJeCvlezvbmY9Av4dWvkdXiL5U6vWEFbBDowXc8flCxTBT4aW8IMHbsqAyLWHMDo4WcZMJXPM8eeDPkYpOBetYza_ED6eMzY72ACP5BMos9LSZIhbWHnpIdz3G0Q7zJmHxP2s0_2dwlIB-HGWJzm60jJcUP4q5aJhpXF8NliuZKPNlj4owNSwH8SpTVmxG6VR7_nOcLad6zsr_3VWJfeSSp-HnaTab6fm6Dsok5lCgf3PT790PPvYLkgkztcoKpRB0lTIYuGMu6haPijBPoD6HCoGGka4Yrk9jP9EkTDi47zRUz2gIVc0wfBqnJ1UEDOJABcO66H69YjriKc5LRXk8jTXTIgKXD34Ys8xAiXE6C-kagdt2HghsX7AuF3qXw_hpCOmbb48YNGxXCZ9mCpVRZhpAaKD7YoRZ-_0hQtO8B0HwLbq008hiU8DkE3QASN9fsxmDLEWtULPq7-kDi4t6tqldF2Z5pFYKRe2WLdOrNWwaN9pTL84RngFgO0kyKFkRm9FM6O__k1HB1bqQufv-Lj-_NN-mC_k0yVarnJNekil4--4uf9IVqmCixVzWZ1Skxami0dGcTnZNL2bujQXmiJLHocgiGAmL3bEQJ-hUi65bc32Y2ZNZrIonLNabYbSx4gVjzVOLfXMBihTYWyGnVNgbzrlRdrP-7DHZMDRbwMAUqaUUVIdlwuea8ktu4cAsYOOjAj2iiTLGzNlSPx0yRSOqaGOgwBsN7ZKG0Q6uPvFYsUTxiJkTmC1XvcW9tG3LfOeuMPcEXOltSHfS-nBqw9LKeTZ-kQeKeF_JGMoQfHfYBa8ZvU2YH3kcMviQdTvKX2wWFExdLam4kWGW_oRtRxg9NzBfEQct3NJbOYO8JOQZY9Z7vsz15X3CmEXzdDe0pFhkcLP_YkArDdJj6E0gb7x223HqlgLivVcQxC3eLuTg3Ln9CHaw6J2mK9z9YXxnLt4slFqlnUbj6enpfEXVQs7YV5gRz0O5bKyADeh0Znx8pgU1uvDnSn90Ly8No8aG00X-miLN2RZ3RletCfFt0oa6oHLXF43fARwhXhOB80nbcTE412s7CJxtBwGGn9v2WwGGn0MIAha4TYxXHN9HWeu4Ls5aErQx_Gw3wFjhOC0PI9YhPk49v2V7CJznkQCTLG7QbGNwxCEtDK4V-Cixfrtto3BgB8rNvoMJh9t0m01UOJoYscT2iYMywwlQ0YVs8THRDbw2JguIG6DkBq2ghVGv7bYwYu2gRWxUMpPAR1U0p-mhcHa7japoLRdVW5ygHaDk-j7GDtKyCa5ComtQC7cjuCi5LuQzJl08AkUSY2_TczB5QNqug0p7ULCFKmp-G7djtXyUHTbxUdWFAEMMziU-Kq9sBxXeZsvxUFtlgCqSfkBQNdJuHcoW6N523Q7cQKNmejrdyemLdxKmav1Mf7m5MX3eR86erJTRJFxMVKJnoX-kXP7X5FHrvGnnk9dbRtWQrooeWCOKqc0vZjZF1TWHST8x8-amGdbAvy7rZ9BrnbvFO8UL090W7aW-nrC8Vc1SBgOqjKNPjK5gHGLFLJYfigHQzKnF4DWmCTS_HWvcHfdr78AEDajdShGx2PqUgLqLWi-hM2gzO5ZWpjZK2Ix_7Vj6lyiv3EyyGeammEM7lt2sFa7vWLdn5m_N-GbMvnQsYtcGy5XgIdfP7dq3MNfp-8tpylrQ1HKbv-lJFbSH2dzq6XHEyo9Pat8Unacdujkh-f4NiOas0zz3vv_-L-Kf2e6_LSUtChS7YxSTGUMZjTXWMhSQMudePvHbmxFAuy7v74XcHDy-ZWLJ1C7RtoeTecCOBms_Rvv8cphFJk90ZXWn6zSFQaTI7QPL6BDpSzIbR_Y66kpKlVZU6JAtJ5S6YkKVJLmB4enBclAq2YdUcqq5F-cE-xeRudWU9KtJ86t7s0o-nYhAvtbKCjqQSX4VOSfS71bIR_2GpDxjp_oqIlXkudVygVTLPPd0eDCOLcv2UHpVNBxVd7wK-lSogc4pMdHayg_dS4bvsJcr5ZdXhQi1JH_YZg8EopKdXmW32hXi7ldbSU619HXKZ5lbvexXyGlS2fkOZmW6GFAFtX-i-UFGsnoU_ApZWT0MP5Eu2JKsaZGrBg-t4Lkxj-e4TqB0oTjq3orlAh_PKuY4CD-R6mFwK3vLq2INZr1UT_ITKnWXmWA_NkH5vAkDozmgMIcB5pcyMp7x-Q8_gNEjJtdvR_sxW67NSKx_iTqVUjAaF-cMxfvqgsNF4-X_lPkfS2qdKA==

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

First steps

  1. Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
  2. Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
  3. Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
  4. Open a pull request that references the issue number.

Research direction

Start by reproducing the supplied build code and checking the calculation handling for Wintertide Brand, Bonechill, Elemental Focus, and the helmet chill enchant. Compare the Calcs output with Elemental Focus enabled and disabled, then verify that both Wintertide Brand lines and the enchant's increased chill effect are represented correctly.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Assessment

Tech stack
lua
Domain
tooling
Issue type
Bug
Difficulty
4/5
Estimated time
3-5 days
Activity status
Stale
Clarity
Mostly clear
Newbie friendliness
35/100

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.