Inconsistent Go To Definition Behavior

How are you using the lua-language-server?

Visual Studio Code Extension (sumneko.lua)

Which OS are you using?

Windows

What is the issue affecting?

Type Checking

Expected Behaviour

Consider the following code:

---@class A
---@field t table<string, number>
---@field s string

---@class B
---@field a A

---@type B
local b = {
    a = {
        t = { x = 1 },
        s = 'hi',
    }
}

When you ctrl+click (or Go To Definition) on a inside the declaration of variable b, the cursor moves to ---@field a A in the type definition of class B. That's useful behavior. Similarly, when you do the same on s inside the nested a declaration, it goes to --@field s string in class A as expected.

When you click on t however (in t = { x = 1 }, it takes you to the builtin.lua meta file and places the cursor on the definition for tables @class table<K, V>: { [K]: V }. Not only is that behavior not consistent with the above, but it's also completely useless.

Another example (and probably different issue) is if you move the variable declaration to another file, like this:

File 1:

---@class A
---@field t table<string, number>
---@field s string

---@class B
---@field a A

File 2:

---@type B
local b = {
    a = {
        t = { x = 1 },
        s = 'hi',
    }
}

Now going to the definition of t still takes you to builtin.lua, but going to the definition of a, or s does nothing at all. I assume it's because it's treating their "definition" as the same line where they are declared in File 2.

Ideally I would like Go to Definition to do something useful inside table declarations and take me to the type annotation. But if that's not possible it should at least be consistent. In my opinion it should never take you to builtin.lua if there's another more suitable definition.

I think this worked fine in a previous version. I only started to see this behavior in the last few months.

Actual Behaviour

See above.

Reproduction steps

See above.

Additional Notes

No response

Log File

No response

Inizia con gli snippet Lua nell’issue e riproduci Go To Definition nell’estensione Visual Studio Code su Windows, confrontando le dichiarazioni inline e tra file. Traccia il motivo per cui il campo t viene risolto in builtin.lua, mentre a e s vengono risolti diversamente. Il lavoro è completato quando la navigazione ai campi delle tabelle raggiunge coerentemente l’annotazione di tipo pertinente o evita la definizione della tabella builtin, con copertura di regressione per entrambi gli esempi.