tailscale / tailscale/tailscale
Tailscale can't work around a blocked DERP node
- Dominant language
- Go
- Stars
- 36.5k
- Forks
- 3.2k
- Avg merge
- 2d 3h
- Merged PRs (30d)
- 123
Description
### What is the issue?
I'm experimenting with the Tailscale networks, end goal is to determine if it's suitable for our organization. **Right now we are trying Headscale** because of the restrictions I describe below. AFAIU this shouldn't matter for the purposes of the issue.
Some of my hosts have a whitelist-based firewall due to regulations. I have custom DERP nodes which are whitelisted. A restricted host uses them to connect to other hosts, and everything works correctly this far.
However, when I add another *non-whitelisted* DERP node to the map, I can't connect to the hosts that choose it as their home DERP node from a restricted host. Looking at the traffic, it seems that Tailscale tries (unsuccessfully) to connect to the non-whitelisted DERP node STUN and TLS ports, without trying other connection routes. When I disable the non-whitelisted DERP node, everything works correctly.
I'm not sure if it's a misconfiguration on my side, a bug or if Tailscale doesn't support this kind of setup right now. I tried to find a technical description of how the connection is established, but failed — maybe someone can point me at it?
I thought of solving this with HTTPS proxies, this should also allow us to move to the official Tailscale servers. Even though, it would be nice to get a confirmation that's the way the protocol works.
Thanks!
### Steps to reproduce
1. Setup two custom DERP nodes DerpA and DerpB. Disable the default regions;
2. Setup two hosts, HostA and HostB. Setup a firewall on HostA whitelisting only DerpA. HostB must be located close to the non-whitelisted DerpB;
3. Check that HostA has DerpA as the home DERP node, and HostB has DerpB;
4. On HostA: `ping hostb`.
Observe that ping doesn't work. Observe traffic on HostA; notice that it tries (unsuccessfully) to connect to DerpB.
### Are there any recent changes that introduced the issue?
_No response_
### OS
Linux
### OS version
NixOS 23.11
### Tailscale version
1.46.1
### Other software
Headscale 0.22.3
### Bug report
-
Contributor guide
Assessment
This issue has not been assessed yet.