githubnext / githubnext/crane

Expose Crane run cadence as an installer choice and tuning guide

Open
#8 0 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
documentation enhancement
Dominant language
Python
Stars
10
Forks
0
PR merge metrics
No merged PRs in 30d

Description

## Background

The githubnext/apm migration needed faster iteration than the default Crane cadence. APM locally changed the Crane workflow schedule from `every 6h` to `every 20m` so Crane could converge in hours rather than days while maintainers were actively watching.

That should not necessarily become the upstream default. It should become an explicit installation and tuning choice.

## Problem

The upstream Crane workflow defaults to a fixed schedule. The README explains that users can tune cadence, and `install.md` asks about migration frequency, but the installed workflow still needs a clear path for applying and documenting the chosen cadence.

Different migrations need different cadences:

- Active, high-attention migration: every 20m or every 1h.
- Normal migration in a busy repository: every 6h.
- Low-risk background migration: daily or weekly.
- Multiple active migrations: cadence interacts with the scheduler because each run selects only one migration.

If the cadence is too slow, Crane appears idle and migrations take too long. If it is too fast, maintainers get too many commits and CI runs.

## Proposed implementation

Update Crane installation and documentation so cadence is a first-class choice.

Implementation options:

1. In `install.md`, keep the frequency prompt but make the follow-through explicit:
- The agent should edit `workflows/crane.md` to set `on.schedule` to the selected cadence.
- Then it should run `gh aw compile crane`.

2. In `README.md`, add a cadence tuning section with examples:

```yaml
on:
schedule: every 20m
```

```yaml
on:
schedule: every 1h
```

```yaml
on:
schedule: every 6h
```

3. Explain trade-offs:
- Faster cadence gets feedback quickly but increases CI usage and review pressure.
- Slower cadence is calmer but may make migrations look stalled.
- For multiple migrations, faster workflow cadence may still run only one selected migration per trigger.

4. Consider adding guidance to `create-migration.md` for per-migration `schedule:` frontmatter versus workflow-level cadence. Users should understand both knobs:
- Workflow cadence: how often Crane wakes up.
- Migration schedule: whether a specific migration is due when Crane wakes up.

## Suggested test coverage

- Documentation test or prompt test that asserts `install.md` says to update `workflows/crane.md` and compile after selecting cadence.
- If installer automation exists, test that the selected cadence changes the workflow source before compilation.

## Acceptance criteria

- A new Crane installer run asks for cadence and applies it to the workflow source.
- Documentation explains recommended cadence ranges and trade-offs.
- Documentation distinguishes workflow wake-up cadence from per-migration schedule frontmatter.
- Users can reproduce the APM-style fast loop intentionally without hand-editing undocumented workflow internals.

## Provenance

This came from githubnext/apm, where changing Crane to `every 20m` helped the Python-to-Go migration converge much faster while humans were actively reviewing.

Contributor guide

No contributing guide indexed for this repository

Assessment

This issue has not been assessed yet.

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.