facebookresearch / facebookresearch/segment-anything

the results in gpu and cpu are different.

Open
#751 0 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
Dominant language
Jupyter Notebook
Stars
54.9k
Forks
6.4k
PR merge metrics
No merged PRs in 30d

Description

i'm using the sam encoder which is based on vit model to encode an image. but it seems that the result on gpu is different from cpu.
there is some simple test code:
```python
>>> from segment_anything.modeling.image_encoder import ImageEncoderViT
>>> import torch
>>> from functools import partial
>>> model = ImageEncoderViT(depth=32,embed_dim=1280,img_size=1024,mlp_ratio=4,norm_layer=partial(torch.nn.LayerNorm, eps=1e-6),num_heads=16,patch_size=16,qkv_bias=True,use_rel_pos=True,global_attn_indexes=[7, 15, 23, 31],window_size=14,out_chans=256,)
>>> input = torch.randn((1,3,1024,1024))
>>> a = model(input)
>>> model = model.to('cuda:0')
>>> input = input.to('cuda:0')
>>> b = model(input)
>>> a
tensor([[[[ 1.8612e-01, 1.1807e+00, 1.7301e+00, ..., 1.9374e+00,
1.0217e+00, 1.0662e+00],
[-2.9578e-01, -5.7185e-01, 1.4766e-01, ..., 9.9894e-01,
-8.1706e-01, 1.1982e+00],
[-5.4977e-01, 5.0114e-01, -2.0103e-01, ..., 1.3675e+00,
3.3389e-01, -7.0931e-01],
...,
[ 1.6346e+00, 9.0330e-01, 1.0282e+00, ..., -6.7727e-01,
-2.4132e-01, 7.0905e-01],
[-6.3068e-01, 4.9860e-01, -7.3669e-01, ..., -1.4967e-01,
1.5211e+00, 6.1666e-01],
[ 3.5227e-01, 1.3268e+00, 1.9159e-01, ..., 3.1407e-03,
-7.5928e-01, 5.6686e-01]],

[[-1.1724e+00, -4.8071e-02, 6.3057e-01, ..., 4.3397e-01,
4.8736e-01, -3.8219e-01],
[ 6.6380e-01, -3.5226e-01, -3.4688e-01, ..., 1.2240e+00,
1.1453e+00, 2.5559e-01],
[-4.9017e-01, 1.3543e-01, -1.9186e-01, ..., 7.8529e-01,
-1.0934e+00, 4.1711e-01],
...,
[-1.8451e+00, -1.3379e+00, 7.4616e-01, ..., 1.5989e-01,
1.2872e-01, 2.6470e-01],
[ 8.1469e-01, -1.2960e+00, -1.4881e-01, ..., 2.3249e-01,
1.6365e+00, 1.5253e+00],
[ 1.1759e+00, -7.4470e-02, -2.3624e-01, ..., 7.0021e-01,
1.7946e-01, -8.6396e-01]],

[[-1.6003e-01, 9.0498e-01, 4.7817e-01, ..., -1.3752e+00,
8.6951e-01, 6.1081e-02],
[-7.8159e-01, -8.6177e-02, 2.3580e-01, ..., -1.1550e-01,
1.6117e+00, 8.6789e-02],
[-1.0102e+00, 4.7301e-01, -1.3565e-01, ..., 1.6855e+00,
1.0961e+00, -5.8807e-01],
...,
[-1.0291e+00, 2.5171e-02, -3.0832e-01, ..., -1.0538e+00,
-7.5840e-01, 7.3209e-01],
[-8.3241e-02, 1.3793e+00, -2.4078e-01, ..., -3.6528e-01,
-1.9410e+00, 3.2880e-01],
[-1.1042e+00, -3.1801e-01, 3.9523e-01, ..., -9.5052e-01,
1.4437e+00, 1.0042e+00]],

...,

[[ 8.1897e-01, -6.1691e-01, 2.1173e-02, ..., 5.6371e-01,
6.6797e-01, -1.5076e+00],
[ 4.8713e-01, -1.4290e+00, -1.2916e+00, ..., -1.6410e+00,
3.3599e-01, -2.6969e+00],
[ 4.1811e-01, -9.8550e-01, -3.5540e-02, ..., -1.7273e-01,
-2.0933e-01, 3.4603e-02],
...,
[-1.1345e+00, -3.2653e-01, 6.7625e-01, ..., -1.5426e+00,
-1.9519e+00, 5.1214e-01],
[-1.7559e+00, -6.6151e-01, -8.6155e-01, ..., -1.1955e-01,
9.3050e-02, -8.3560e-01],
[ 5.3564e-01, -1.0189e+00, -1.0242e-01, ..., -2.9650e+00,
1.5463e+00, -1.3964e-01]],

[[ 1.4698e+00, 1.3735e+00, 1.9960e+00, ..., -6.1414e-02,
-2.1789e-02, -2.3297e-01],
[ 1.5900e+00, 7.5189e-01, 1.2917e+00, ..., 2.9176e-01,
4.7061e-01, -1.3825e-01],
[ 3.8520e-02, 8.2141e-02, 8.5229e-01, ..., 4.3940e-01,
-8.7757e-01, 1.6680e+00],
...,
[-5.8654e-01, 4.2654e-01, 1.2356e+00, ..., 4.9412e-01,
-1.7638e+00, 7.5148e-01],
[-1.5260e+00, 3.3236e-01, -4.0470e-01, ..., -4.5623e-01,
1.0419e+00, -6.7022e-01],
[-1.4664e-01, -1.3360e+00, -1.3063e-01, ..., -4.8114e-01,
8.4078e-01, 4.9047e-01]],

[[-6.5096e-01, -8.3868e-02, -5.0712e-01, ..., -1.2956e+00,
-1.7728e+00, 2.0674e-03],
[ 5.6505e-01, -4.3940e-01, -5.6637e-01, ..., -9.7842e-02,
-1.8229e-01, -9.4668e-01],
[ 9.9391e-02, -1.8613e+00, -2.3191e-01, ..., 5.4263e-01,
3.3098e-01, 5.7215e-01],
...,
[-5.9365e-01, -4.4359e-01, 5.7365e-01, ..., 1.4440e+00,
-8.0939e-01, 4.5247e-01],
[-4.4945e-01, 8.4763e-01, -4.5822e-01, ..., 1.0057e-01,
-2.0821e+00, -4.1656e-01],
[ 1.1467e+00, -2.7241e-01, 2.2380e-01, ..., 1.3074e+00,
1.1064e+00, -1.9652e-01]]]], grad_fn=)
>>> b
tensor([[[[ 1.8613e-01, 1.1808e+00, 1.7298e+00, ..., 1.9373e+00,
1.0220e+00, 1.0663e+00],
[-2.9474e-01, -5.7186e-01, 1.4721e-01, ..., 9.9892e-01,
-8.1679e-01, 1.1981e+00],
[-5.4976e-01, 5.0110e-01, -2.0095e-01, ..., 1.3670e+00,
3.3403e-01, -7.0914e-01],
...,
[ 1.6345e+00, 9.0402e-01, 1.0286e+00, ..., -6.7679e-01,
-2.4079e-01, 7.0921e-01],
[-6.3119e-01, 4.9833e-01, -7.3691e-01, ..., -1.4916e-01,
1.5213e+00, 6.1662e-01],
[ 3.5211e-01, 1.3276e+00, 1.9139e-01, ..., 3.5384e-03,
-7.5894e-01, 5.6629e-01]],

[[-1.1723e+00, -4.8274e-02, 6.2981e-01, ..., 4.3429e-01,
4.8750e-01, -3.8201e-01],
[ 6.6343e-01, -3.5284e-01, -3.4701e-01, ..., 1.2244e+00,
1.1450e+00, 2.5615e-01],
[-4.8977e-01, 1.3493e-01, -1.9164e-01, ..., 7.8547e-01,
-1.0936e+00, 4.1790e-01],
...,
[-1.8454e+00, -1.3374e+00, 7.4570e-01, ..., 1.6032e-01,
1.2813e-01, 2.6515e-01],
[ 8.1454e-01, -1.2965e+00, -1.4904e-01, ..., 2.3186e-01,
1.6366e+00, 1.5256e+00],
[ 1.1758e+00, -7.4639e-02, -2.3658e-01, ..., 6.9997e-01,
1.7988e-01, -8.6346e-01]],

[[-1.5887e-01, 9.0525e-01, 4.7847e-01, ..., -1.3753e+00,
8.6982e-01, 6.0748e-02],
[-7.8159e-01, -8.6499e-02, 2.3592e-01, ..., -1.1533e-01,
1.6125e+00, 8.6588e-02],
[-1.0099e+00, 4.7295e-01, -1.3520e-01, ..., 1.6858e+00,
1.0969e+00, -5.8796e-01],
...,
[-1.0280e+00, 2.5919e-02, -3.0776e-01, ..., -1.0534e+00,
-7.5797e-01, 7.3154e-01],
[-8.2854e-02, 1.3790e+00, -2.4053e-01, ..., -3.6519e-01,
-1.9405e+00, 3.2865e-01],
[-1.1040e+00, -3.1811e-01, 3.9496e-01, ..., -9.5097e-01,
1.4436e+00, 1.0055e+00]],

...,

[[ 8.1913e-01, -6.1696e-01, 2.1298e-02, ..., 5.6404e-01,
6.6752e-01, -1.5076e+00],
[ 4.8712e-01, -1.4296e+00, -1.2915e+00, ..., -1.6405e+00,
3.3607e-01, -2.6966e+00],
[ 4.1837e-01, -9.8499e-01, -3.5222e-02, ..., -1.7220e-01,
-2.0918e-01, 3.4825e-02],
...,
[-1.1339e+00, -3.2579e-01, 6.7619e-01, ..., -1.5426e+00,
-1.9515e+00, 5.1229e-01],
[-1.7551e+00, -6.6145e-01, -8.6196e-01, ..., -1.1973e-01,
9.2693e-02, -8.3518e-01],
[ 5.3598e-01, -1.0185e+00, -1.0261e-01, ..., -2.9648e+00,
1.5463e+00, -1.3949e-01]],

[[ 1.4701e+00, 1.3737e+00, 1.9956e+00, ..., -6.1765e-02,
-2.1836e-02, -2.3352e-01],
[ 1.5898e+00, 7.5188e-01, 1.2918e+00, ..., 2.9170e-01,
4.7040e-01, -1.3936e-01],
[ 3.8367e-02, 8.2116e-02, 8.5211e-01, ..., 4.3911e-01,
-8.7742e-01, 1.6678e+00],
...,
[-5.8667e-01, 4.2650e-01, 1.2358e+00, ..., 4.9508e-01,
-1.7640e+00, 7.5134e-01],
[-1.5257e+00, 3.3204e-01, -4.0525e-01, ..., -4.5664e-01,
1.0411e+00, -6.7079e-01],
[-1.4586e-01, -1.3357e+00, -1.3083e-01, ..., -4.8108e-01,
8.4058e-01, 4.8972e-01]],

[[-6.5139e-01, -8.3864e-02, -5.0726e-01, ..., -1.2955e+00,
-1.7731e+00, 2.0270e-03],
[ 5.6447e-01, -4.3915e-01, -5.6635e-01, ..., -9.7440e-02,
-1.8280e-01, -9.4630e-01],
[ 9.9024e-02, -1.8613e+00, -2.3198e-01, ..., 5.4247e-01,
3.3030e-01, 5.7333e-01],
...,
[-5.9371e-01, -4.4316e-01, 5.7401e-01, ..., 1.4442e+00,
-8.1024e-01, 4.5189e-01],
[-4.4987e-01, 8.4775e-01, -4.5821e-01, ..., 1.0086e-01,
-2.0822e+00, -4.1624e-01],
[ 1.1466e+00, -2.7306e-01, 2.2303e-01, ..., 1.3072e+00,
1.1065e+00, -1.9689e-01]]]], device='cuda:2',
grad_fn=)
>>>
```

and i found that the accuracy is good before the neck layer in vit model. but after neck layer, the results in gpu and cpu are very different. i test it on torch1.13.1+cu118, torch2.2.2+cu118,and the bug always happen

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

Assessment

This issue has not been assessed yet.

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.