review: QUICK path returns PASS WITH WARNINGS when only INFO findings exist

Observed

In the evals/ review suite pilot (2026-09-18), case 01-quick-clean-log-fix (a one-file diff that rewords a comment and a debug log line) routed to QUICK, raised a single INFO finding, and closed with:

PASS WITH WARNINGS — no critical or correctness-breaking issues; one INFO-level nit on log/output consistency.

A second pilot run on the same prompt returned PASS, so the behavior is intermittent.

Expected

skills/review/SKILL.md defines the QUICK verdicts as:

• PASS: no critical or warning findings
• PASS WITH WARNINGS: warnings only
• FAIL: one or more critical findings

INFO-only output should be PASS.

Suggested fix

Make the verdict rule explicit right above the verdict line in the QUICK output section, for example: "Count only CRITICAL and WARNING findings when choosing the verdict. INFO findings never change it."

How to verify

Run the suite; grader no-false-findings on case 01 fails when this happens.

Start with skills/review/SKILL.md and inspect the QUICK verdict rules around the output section. Run the review suite, especially grader no-false-findings on case 01, and confirm that INFO-only findings produce PASS while warning findings still produce PASS WITH WARNINGS.