black7375 / black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix

Trying to enable dedicated search button can make address bar thicker on compact density

Open
#959 1 comment 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
Class::Padding Component::Toolbar Env::Windows Issue::Bug
Dominant language
SCSS
Stars
5.9k
Forks
202
PR merge metrics
No merged PRs in 30d

Description

### Describe the bug

I don't know what the exact circumstances are, but it can be reproduced when you restart Firefox after enabling the `browser.urlbar.scotchBonnet.enableOverride`.

Changing the compact layout to normal and then back to compact will temporarily solve this issue, but only until the next Firefox instance.

Try to reproduce only from Firefox v129.0.0.

If you don't know about which dedicated search button I'm talking about, then check this Nightly blog: https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2024/07/18/100-webdriver-bidi-and-101-more-these-weeks-in-firefox-issue-164/

### Expected behavior

Fix the address bar to use normal height on compact density.

### Screenshots

Look at the address bar how it actually looks:
![image](https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/62951bbf-3942-4d76-a462-acf640256999)

Expected height of address bar:
![image](https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/379c45b3-8ca2-4698-9610-88330b856802)

### OS

Windows 10

### OS - Others

_No response_

### Firefox Version

v129.0.0 (64-bit)

### Distribution

- [X] [Original Lepton](https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix)
- [ ] [Lepton's photon style](https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/tree/photon-style)
- [ ] [Lepton's proton style](https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/tree/proton-style)

### Theme

- [X] Light
- [X] Dark
- [ ] Alpenglow (System: Light)
- [ ] Alpenglow (System: Dark)
- [ ] System Default
- [ ] Others: (e.g. [Photon Colors](https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/photon-colors/), [Google Chrome Dark](https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/google-chrome-dark/), [Fairytale Of Nature](https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/fairytale-of-nature/))

### Theme - More Info

_No response_

### `user.js` setup

user.js setup

```javascript
// ** Theme Default Options ****************************************************
// userchrome.css usercontent.css activate
user_pref("toolkit.legacyUserProfileCustomizations.stylesheets", true);

// Fill SVG Color
user_pref("svg.context-properties.content.enabled", true);

// Restore Compact Mode - 89 Above
user_pref("browser.compactmode.show", true);

// about:home Search Bar - 89 Above
user_pref("browser.newtabpage.activity-stream.improvesearch.handoffToAwesomebar", false);

// CSS's `:has()` selector #457 - 103 Above
user_pref("layout.css.has-selector.enabled", true);

// Browser Theme Based Scheme - Will be activate 95 Above
// user_pref("layout.css.prefers-color-scheme.content-override", 3);

// ** Theme Related Options ****************************************************
// == Theme Distribution Settings ==============================================
// The rows that are located continuously must be changed `true`/`false` explicitly because there is a collision.
// https://github.com/black7375/Firefox-UI-Fix/wiki/Options#important
user_pref("userChrome.tab.connect_to_window", true); // Original, Photon
user_pref("userChrome.tab.color_like_toolbar", true); // Original, Photon

user_pref("userChrome.tab.lepton_like_padding", true); // Original
user_pref("userChrome.tab.photon_like_padding", false); // Photon

user_pref("userChrome.tab.dynamic_separator", true); // Original, Proton
user_pref("userChrome.tab.static_separator", false); // Photon
user_pref("userChrome.tab.static_separator.selected_accent", false); // Just option
user_pref("userChrome.tab.bar_separator", false); // Just option

user_pref("userChrome.tab.newtab_button_like_tab", true); // Original
user_pref("userChrome.tab.newtab_button_smaller", false); // Photon
user_pref("userChrome.tab.newtab_button_proton", false); // Proton

user_pref("userChrome.icon.panel_full", true); // Original, Proton
user_pref("userChrome.icon.panel_photon", false); // Photon

// Original Only
user_pref("userChrome.tab.box_shadow", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner", true);

// Photon Only
user_pref("userChrome.tab.photon_like_contextline", false);
user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_tab", false);

// == Theme Compatibility Settings =============================================
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.accent_color", true); // Firefox v103 Below
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.covered_header_image", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.panel_cutoff", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.navbar_top_border", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.dynamic_separator", true); // Need dynamic_separator

// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os.linux_non_native_titlebar_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os.windows_maximized", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os.win11", true);

// == Theme Custom Settings ====================================================
// -- User Chrome --------------------------------------------------------------
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.private", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.proton_color.dark_blue_accent", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.monospace", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.transparent.frame", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.transparent.menu", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.transparent.panel", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.theme.non_native_menu", true); // only for linux

// user_pref("userChrome.decoration.disable_panel_animate", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.decoration.disable_sidebar_animate", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.decoration.panel_button_separator", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.decoration.panel_arrow", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tab", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tab.opacity", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tab.blur", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.tabbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.navbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.bookmarkbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.sidebar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.fill_urlbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.back_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.forward_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.page_action", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.toolbar_overlap", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.autohide.toolbar_overlap.allow_layout_shift", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.tab_icon", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.tab_icon.always", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.tabbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.navbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.private_indicator", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.titlebar_container", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.sidebar_header", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.sidebar_header.vertical_tab_only", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.urlbar_iconbox", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.urlbar_iconbox.label_only", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.bookmarkbar_icon", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.bookmarkbar_label", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.hidden.disabled_menu", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.centered.tab", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.centered.tab.label", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.centered.urlbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.centered.bookmarkbar", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.counter.tab", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.counter.bookmark_menu", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.combined.nav_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.combined.nav_button.home_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.combined.urlbar.nav_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.combined.urlbar.home_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.combined.urlbar.reload_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.combined.sub_button.none_background", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.combined.sub_button.as_normal", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_button", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_dialog", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_panel", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_panelitem", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_menupopup", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_menuitem", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_infobox", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_toolbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_field", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_urlView_item", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.rounding.square_checklabel", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.padding.first_tab", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.first_tab.always", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.drag_space", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.drag_space.maximized", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.padding.toolbar_button.compact", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.menu_compact", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.bookmark_menu.compact", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.urlView_expanding", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.urlView_result", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.padding.panel_header", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.urlbar.iconbox_with_separator", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.urlView.as_commandbar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.urlView.full_width_padding", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.urlView.always_show_page_actions", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.urlView.move_icon_to_left", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.urlView.go_button_when_typing", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.urlView.focus_item_border", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.as_titlebar", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.fill_width", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.multi_row", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.unscroll", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom.above_bookmark", true); // Need on_bottom
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom.menubar_on_top", true); // Need on_bottom
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.on_bottom.hidden_single_tab", true); // Need on_bottom
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner.combine_navbar", true); // Need one_liner
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner.tabbar_first", true); // Need one_liner
// user_pref("userChrome.tabbar.one_liner.responsive", true); // Need one_liner

// user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.all", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.australis", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.edge", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.chrome", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.chrome_legacy", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.bottom_rounded_corner.wave", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.always_show_tab_icon", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_pinned", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_pinned.always", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_pinned.background", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_hover.always", true); // Need close_button_at_hover
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_hover.with_selected", true); // Need close_button_at_hover
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_show_label", true); // Need remove sound_hide_label
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.container.on_top", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.container.always_long", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_with_favicons.on_center", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.tab.selected_bold", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.navbar.as_sidebar", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.bookmarkbar.multi_row", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.findbar.floating_on_top", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.panel.remove_strip", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.panel.full_width_separator", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.panel.full_width_padding", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.sidebar.overlap", true);

// user_pref("userChrome.icon.disabled", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.icon.account_image_to_right", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.icon.account_label_to_right", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.icon.menu.full", true);
// user_pref("userChrome.icon.global_menu.mac", true);

// -- User Content -------------------------------------------------------------
// user_pref("userContent.player.ui.twoline", true);

// user_pref("userContent.newTab.hidden_logo", true);
// user_pref("userContent.newTab.background_image", true); // Need wallpaper image to `userContent.css`. :root { --uc-newTab-wallpaper: url("../icons/background_image.png"); }

// user_pref("userContent.page.proton_color.dark_blue_accent", true);
// user_pref("userContent.page.proton_color.system_accent", true);
// user_pref("userContent.page.dark_mode.pdf", true);
// user_pref("userContent.page.monospace", true);

// == Theme Default Settings ===================================================
// -- User Chrome --------------------------------------------------------------
user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.theme", true);
user_pref("userChrome.compatibility.os", true);

user_pref("userChrome.theme.built_in_contrast", true);
user_pref("userChrome.theme.system_default", true);
user_pref("userChrome.theme.proton_color", true);
user_pref("userChrome.theme.proton_chrome", true); // Need proton_color
user_pref("userChrome.theme.fully_color", true); // Need proton_color
user_pref("userChrome.theme.fully_dark", true); // Need proton_color

user_pref("userChrome.decoration.cursor", true);
user_pref("userChrome.decoration.field_border", true);
user_pref("userChrome.decoration.download_panel", true);
user_pref("userChrome.decoration.animate", true);

user_pref("userChrome.padding.tabbar_width", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.tabbar_height", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.toolbar_button", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.navbar_width", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.urlbar", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.bookmarkbar", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.infobar", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.menu", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.bookmark_menu", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.global_menubar", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.panel", true);
user_pref("userChrome.padding.popup_panel", true);

user_pref("userChrome.tab.multi_selected", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.unloaded", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.letters_cleary", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.close_button_at_hover", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_hide_label", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.sound_with_favicons", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.pip", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.container", true);
user_pref("userChrome.tab.crashed", true);

user_pref("userChrome.fullscreen.overlap", true);
user_pref("userChrome.fullscreen.show_bookmarkbar", true);

user_pref("userChrome.icon.library", true);
user_pref("userChrome.icon.panel", true);
user_pref("userChrome.icon.menu", true);
user_pref("userChrome.icon.context_menu", true);
user_pref("userChrome.icon.global_menu", true);
user_pref("userChrome.icon.global_menubar", true);
user_pref("userChrome.icon.1-25px_stroke", true);

// -- User Content -------------------------------------------------------------
user_pref("userContent.player.ui", true);
user_pref("userContent.player.icon", true);
user_pref("userContent.player.noaudio", true);
user_pref("userContent.player.size", true);
user_pref("userContent.player.click_to_play", true);
user_pref("userContent.player.animate", true);

user_pref("userContent.newTab.full_icon", true);
user_pref("userContent.newTab.animate", true);
user_pref("userContent.newTab.pocket_to_last", true);
user_pref("userContent.newTab.searchbar", true);

user_pref("userContent.page.field_border", true);
user_pref("userContent.page.illustration", true);
user_pref("userContent.page.proton_color", true);
user_pref("userContent.page.dark_mode", true); // Need proton_color
user_pref("userContent.page.proton", true); // Need proton_color

// ** Useful Options ***********************************************************
// Tab preview
// https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2024/02/06/a-preview-of-tab-previews-these-weeks-in-firefox-issue-153/
user_pref("browser.tabs.cardPreview.enabled", true);

// Paste suggestion at urlbar
// https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2023/12/04/url-gonna-want-to-check-this-out-these-weeks-in-firefox-issue-150/
user_pref("browser.urlbar.clipboard.featureGate", true);

// Integrated calculator at urlbar
user_pref("browser.urlbar.suggest.calculator", true);

// Integrated unit convertor at urlbar
// user_pref("browser.urlbar.unitConversion.enabled", true);

// Draw in Titlebar
// user_pref("browser.tabs.drawInTitlebar", true);
// user_pref("browser.tabs.inTitlebar", 1); // Nightly, 96 Above

// Searchbar, Removed from settings starting with FF v122
// user_pref("browser.search.widget.inNavBar", true);

// Firefox view search
// https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2023/12/14/better-searching-in-firefox-to-close-out-2023-these-weeks-in-firefox-issue-151/
// user_pref("browser.firefox-view.search.enabled", true);
// user_pref("browser.firefox-view.virtual-list.enabled", true);

// Firefox screenshot
// https://blog.nightly.mozilla.org/2024/01/22/happy-new-year-these-weeks-in-firefox-issue-152/
// user_pref("screenshots.browser.component.enabled", true);

// ** Scrolling Settings *******************************************************
// == Only Sharpen Scrolling ===================================================
// Pref Value Original
/*
user_pref("mousewheel.min_line_scroll_amount", 10); // 5
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.durationMinMS", 80); // 50
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.currentVelocityWeighting", "0.15"); // "0.25"
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.stopDecelerationWeighting", "0.6"); // "0.4"
*/

// == Smooth Scrolling ==========================================================
// ** Scrolling Options ********************************************************
// based on natural smooth scrolling v2 by aveyo
// this preset will reset couple extra variables for consistency
// Pref Value Original
/*
user_pref("apz.allow_zooming", true); /// true
user_pref("apz.force_disable_desktop_zooming_scrollbars", false); /// false
user_pref("apz.paint_skipping.enabled", true); /// true
user_pref("apz.windows.use_direct_manipulation", true); /// true
user_pref("dom.event.wheel-deltaMode-lines.always-disabled", true); /// false
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.currentVelocityWeighting", "0.12"); /// "0.25" <- 1. If scroll too slow, set to "0.15"
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.durationToIntervalRatio", 1000); /// 200
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.lines.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.lines.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 200
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.durationMinMS", 0); /// 50
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.mouseWheel.migrationPercent", 100); /// 100
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.continuousMotionMaxDeltaMS", 12); /// 120
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.enabled", true); /// false
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.motionBeginSpringConstant", 200); /// 1250
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.regularSpringConstant", 200); /// 1000
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.slowdownMinDeltaMS", 10); /// 12
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.slowdownMinDeltaRatio", "1.20"); /// "1.3"
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.msdPhysics.slowdownSpringConstant", 1000); /// 2000
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.other.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.other.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pages.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pages.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pixels.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.pixels.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.scrollbars.durationMaxMS", 100); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.scrollbars.durationMinMS", 0); /// 150
user_pref("general.smoothScroll.stopDecelerationWeighting", "0.6"); /// "0.4"
user_pref("layers.async-pan-zoom.enabled", true); /// true
user_pref("layout.css.scroll-behavior.spring-constant", "250.0"); /// "250.0"
user_pref("mousewheel.acceleration.factor", 3); /// 10
user_pref("mousewheel.acceleration.start", -1); /// -1
user_pref("mousewheel.default.delta_multiplier_x", 100); /// 100
user_pref("mousewheel.default.delta_multiplier_y", 100); /// 100
user_pref("mousewheel.default.delta_multiplier_z", 100); /// 100
user_pref("mousewheel.min_line_scroll_amount", 0); /// 5
user_pref("mousewheel.system_scroll_override.enabled", true); /// true <- 2. If scroll too fast, set to false
user_pref("mousewheel.system_scroll_override_on_root_content.enabled", false); /// true
user_pref("mousewheel.transaction.timeout", 1500); /// 1500
user_pref("toolkit.scrollbox.horizontalScrollDistance", 4); /// 5
user_pref("toolkit.scrollbox.verticalScrollDistance", 3); /// 3
*/
```

### Additional context

_No response_

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

Research direction

Start by reproducing the issue in Firefox 129.0 with browser.urlbar.scotchBonnet.enableOverride enabled, compact density selected, and a restart between checks. Compare the address-bar height before and after switching to normal density and back to compact. Done means the address bar retains its normal compact height after restarting Firefox with the dedicated search button enabled.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Assessment

Tech stack
scss
Domain
design, frontend
Issue type
Bug
Difficulty
4/5
Estimated time
3-5 days
Activity status
Stale
Clarity
Needs clarification
Newbie friendliness
35/100

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.