acl-org / acl-org/acl-anthology

Volume type/venue type mismatch

Abierto
#9,437 2 comentarios 0 reacciones 1 asignado Reclamado por @mbollmann Ver en GitHub
bug data-quality venues/SIGs
Lenguaje dominante
Python
Estrellas
796
Forks
408
Merge medio
3 d 13 h
PR fusionados (30 d)
34

Descripción

Volumes obligatory declare a `type` of `"journal"` or `"proceedings"`.

Venues (in data/venues.json) optionally declare a type. In practice, it is only ever declared for `"journal"`.

The following are explicitly inconsistent, with the volume declared as a proceedings and the venue declared as a journal: `2006.tal-1 2006.tal-2 2006.tal-3 2007.tal-1 2007.tal-2 2007.tal-3 2008.tal-1 2008.tal-2 2008.tal-3 2009.tal-1 2009.tal-2 2009.tal-3 2010.tal-1 2010.tal-2 2010.tal-3 2022.ijclclp-1 2022.ijclclp-2 2023.jlcl-1 2023.jlcl-2 O00-2 O00-3 O01-2 O01-3 O02-1 O02-2 O03-4 O03-5 O04-2 O04-3 O05-2 O05-3 O05-4 O05-5 O06-2 O06-3 O06-4 O06-5 O07-3 O07-4 O07-5 O08-3 O08-4 O08-5 O08-6 O09-3 O09-4 O09-5 O09-6 O10-3 O10-4 O10-5 O11-3 O11-4 O12-2 O12-3 O12-4 O12-5 O14-2 O14-3 O14-4 O14-5 O15-2 O15-3 O16-2 O16-3 O17-2 O17-3 O96-2 O97-3 O97-4 O98-3 O98-4 O99-3 O99-4`

DND and JCLIB are journals listed as such at the volume level but with no declared type in venues.json. I will fix that.

Should there be tests for consistency?

Note that there are interesting cases of multiple venues. E.g. https://preview.aclanthology.org/landing-page/volumes/J03-3/ has as the workshop WAC as a venue (they sponsored as special issue). Perhaps the requirement should be that journal-volume => at least one venue declared as a journal, and venues declared as journals should only apply to journal volumes.

Guía de contribución

No hay ninguna guía de contribución indexada para este repositorio

Evaluación

Este issue todavía no se ha evaluado.

Recibe los nuevos issues en tu correo

Un resumen breve de issues de GitHub para principiantes.