Macaulay2 / Macaulay2/M2

bug in rawSelectByDegrees depending on internal degrees

Open
#3,578 4 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub

Nobody has claimed this yet.

Engine
Dominant language
Macaulay2
Stars
435
Forks
297
Avg merge
4d 20h
Merged PRs (30d)
11

Description

I have two multigraded **free** modules M = `source mingens I` and N = `S^(- degrees M)` of rank 86 with the same degrees (though the degree group has torsion) that exhibit bizarre behavior:

First, asking for their degrees takes very long:
```m2
ii110 : elapsedTime degrees N;
-- .757907s elapsed

ii111 : elapsedTime degrees M;
-- 1.68677s elapsed
```
Second, `rawSelectByDegrees` seems to behave differently for them:
```m2
ii104 : rawSelectByDegrees(raw M, d, d)

oo104 = {0}

ii105 : rawSelectByDegrees(raw N, d, d)

oo105 = {0, 3, 5, 12, 14, 42, 71, 73, 80, 83, 85}
```
I presume this is attributable to the internal degree object chosen for them, but I don't understand why:
```m2
oo102 = free(rank 86 degrees = {T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6})
free(rank 86 degrees = {T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1T_2^3T_3^4T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^3T_2^3T_3^4T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^2T_2^6T_3^8T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1T_2^6T_3^8T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^6T_2^6T_3^8T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1^3T_2^4T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1^3T_2^4T_3T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^4T_2^7T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1^4T_2^7T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1^3T_2^7T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^3T_1^3T_2^7T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^2T_1^6T_2^8T_3^2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0T_1^6T_2^8T_3^2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_1^6T_2^8T_3^2T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^3T_2^5T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1^3T_2^5T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1^2T_2^5T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^3T_2^8T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1^5T_2^9T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^2T_2^3T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^3T_2^6T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^2T_2^6T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^2T_2^6T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^5T_2^7T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^4T_2^7T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^4T_1^4T_2^7T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^5T_2^10T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^5T_2^10T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^4T_2^10T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1T_2T_3^5T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^2T_2^4T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^2T_2^4T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1T_2^4T_3^9T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^3T_2^7T_3^13T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^2T_2^7T_3^13T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^6T_1^4T_2^5T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^4T_2^5T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^3T_2^5T_3^6T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^5T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^5T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^4T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^4T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^4T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^3T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^3T_2^8T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^5T_2^11T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^4T_2^11T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^10T_1^4T_2^11T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^10T_1^3T_2^11T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^6T_1^6T_2^9T_3^7T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^5T_1^6T_2^9T_3^7T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^7T_2^12T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^7T_2^12T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^6T_2^12T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^7T_1^6T_2^12T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^4T_2^6T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^3T_2^6T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^3T_2^6T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^4T_2^9T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^4T_2^9T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^3T_2^9T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^6T_2^10T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^6T_2^10T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^8T_1^5T_2^10T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^6T_2^13T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^3T_2^7T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^9T_1^5T_2^8T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^6T_2^11T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^5T_2^11T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^11T_1^5T_2^11T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^10T_1^2T_2^2T_3^10T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^13T_1^3T_2^5T_3^14T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^16T_1^4T_2^8T_3^18T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^10T_1^4T_2^6T_3^11T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^13T_1^5T_2^9T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^5T_2^9T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^4T_2^9T_3^15T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^15T_1^6T_2^12T_3^19T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^15T_1^5T_2^12T_3^19T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^10T_1^6T_2^10T_3^12T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^7T_2^13T_3^16T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^12T_1^6T_2^13T_3^16T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^14T_1^8T_2^16T_3^20T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^14T_1^7T_2^16T_3^20T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6, T_0^14T_1^6T_2^16T_3^20T_4^6T_5^6T_8^2T_10^6T_11^2T_12^2T_13^4T_18^6T_19^6T_20^6})
```
The order of their degrees is the same, so why are they represented differently in the engine? Presumably this has something to do with the ideal, in which case this seems to be a bug in `rawSelectByDegrees`.

cc: @mikestillman any ideas?

Contributor guide

No contributing guide indexed for this repository

First steps

  1. Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
  2. Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
  3. Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
  4. Open a pull request that references the issue number.

Research direction

Reproduce the two rank-86 free-module examples using the reported degrees, then compare the results of degrees and rawSelectByDegrees for M and N. Done means explaining the differing behavior and addressing the reported slowdown or documenting why these equivalent modules are treated differently.

Written by the indexing model from the issue text.

Assessment

Domain
tooling
Issue type
Bug
Difficulty
5/5
Estimated time
Over a week
Activity status
Stale
Clarity
Needs clarification
Newbie friendliness
25/100

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.