ElementsProject / ElementsProject/lightning

RBF onchain of a tx that does not exists.

Open
#7,206 2 comments 0 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
Dominant language
C
Stars
3.1k
Forks
1k
Avg merge
4d 10h
Merged PRs (30d)
13

Description

### Issue and Steps to Reproduce

Hello,

I am using lightning core v24.02.1.

I had a force closed channel with an active HTLC, funds were sent to from bc1qca5lwlfv8qzkchcfqdryfl89szuk2n0c3x2p7vt4gst04keygkns4x68hh to my address (bc1qf7nh8pwt30nxueqekrhapa3wyz98zxu58rfl8l) and 3 days later, the HTLCe expired was sent to the same address bc1qca5lwlfv8qzkchcfqdryfl89szuk2n0c3x2p7vt4gst04keygkns4x68hh and it seems to be stuck.

Since then I see in logs that it is trying to RBF onchain a tx that does not exists non stop:

`
Apr 08 21:00:13 nixos lightningd[1311]: UNUSUAL 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: Peer permanent failure in ONCHAIN: Funding transaction spent
Apr 08 21:00:13 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: State changed from ONCHAIN to FUNDING_SPEND_SEEN
Apr 08 21:00:13 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO lightningd: --------------------------------------------------
Apr 09 16:30:10 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid e20430064a0c8a7f3f6032e555054c68e37b340409456b7fd60e7c0bc6b4e451 (fee 194sat) with txid a1ebed749f7cc64bebfa53e5a4cb9ecb629d9cf53ea4ced43ad0db7e0436e389 (fee 363sat)
Apr 09 16:30:51 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid a1ebed749f7cc64bebfa53e5a4cb9ecb629d9cf53ea4ced43ad0db7e0436e389 (fee 363sat) with txid 8753c0ff777882ac66303f4c81bf4eab2aa17c7e10d55b4f4a337567ae4d21fa (fee 402sat)
Apr 09 16:31:29 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 8753c0ff777882ac66303f4c81bf4eab2aa17c7e10d55b4f4a337567ae4d21fa (fee 402sat) with txid 30e9fd83a2cbb6333ba4693b7d4648e4e6dde053ccdc694b8cecc0c908ee74cc (fee 423sat)
Apr 09 16:35:08 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 30e9fd83a2cbb6333ba4693b7d4648e4e6dde053ccdc694b8cecc0c908ee74cc (fee 423sat) with txid f6c0cc8517529ce32c557d2c6e254645e54ec1f82d2e29fd7fec77c126dd1c9e (fee 426sat)
Apr 09 16:35:55 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid f6c0cc8517529ce32c557d2c6e254645e54ec1f82d2e29fd7fec77c126dd1c9e (fee 426sat) with txid 4947e04fef4bcbdb724f5ee83deec5e0691ebf54aa53bf726e413ceb241cf91d (fee 484sat)
Apr 09 16:39:07 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 4947e04fef4bcbdb724f5ee83deec5e0691ebf54aa53bf726e413ceb241cf91d (fee 484sat) with txid e2f452eaa6c9ab52631f35af7c3af543be2bfb1abc04d9d4542e2d2465b56637 (fee 491sat)
Apr 09 16:45:02 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 03b1b15772747ea70f28254656bd0aecff23153f649612c9eb5bdbc8cae52f38 (fee 489sat) with txid 148dbb77529618e46a107134263991d361dbf7e7577622e02ed853c6fcde1f60 (fee 496sat)
Apr 09 16:46:47 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 148dbb77529618e46a107134263991d361dbf7e7577622e02ed853c6fcde1f60 (fee 496sat) with txid 56269639f3b872cf43c1b3c04a64fa57d9f070c8faeb23e9aa2935971e6e3cc9 (fee 499sat)
Apr 09 16:47:41 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 56269639f3b872cf43c1b3c04a64fa57d9f070c8faeb23e9aa2935971e6e3cc9 (fee 499sat) with txid 5f56eea9fb1b690cd29b24dff77af430bd56600fbe8995d1753fee177ebaad09 (fee 561sat)
Apr 09 16:48:16 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 5f56eea9fb1b690cd29b24dff77af430bd56600fbe8995d1753fee177ebaad09 (fee 561sat) with txid 881b4fee785680c5a8a98245db876c0c3b81ce57a0c9f5467626d2d185eea631 (fee 572sat)
Apr 09 16:49:28 nixos lightningd[1311]: INFO 021cb32426ed1a6be9533801e7c56a70ffc1c360a3a31819c3ae0a72e141d78000-chan#6: RBF onchain txid 881b4fee785680c5a8a98245db876c0c3b81ce57a0c9f5467626d2d185eea631 (fee 572sat) with txid 1a6e3deae273b20ec768b9256d2a266302f6b02331db8036b8e879eec8406024 (fee 574sat)
`

lightning-cli listpeers:

`"status": [
"ONCHAIN:Tracking our own unilateral close",
"ONCHAIN:2 outputs unresolved: waiting confirmation that we spent DELAYED_OUTPUT_TO_US (19e3daf96f323d3bd5b0b5de0bba690d50e51c9e8ce894bdd4d7167763203dff:1) using OUR_DELAYED_RETURN_TO_WALLET

"direction": "out",
"id": 594,
"amount_msat": 34149577,
"expiry": 837088,
"payment_hash": "2af8b9258f39b5594c67c68140ab2e3f2864ed2f75b334473e19da8135d1a368",
"state": "SENT_ADD_ACK_REVOCATION"
`
lightning-cli listtransactions:

`{
"hash": "0e8f317ae114c422295a64e08b477633cbecbb0c4e0a49f80cd0958ad89be97b",
"rawtx": "02000000000101ff3d20637716d7d4bd94e88c9e1ce5500d69ba0bdeb5b0d53b3d326ff9dae3190100000000f00000000147900000000000001600144fa77385cb8be66e6419b0efd0f62e208a711b940347304402205ce00ecebf0c4dabbb1523b24d5472d6c3c2542a2b02a11e9b022b7640b9b43e022050686891b55ad6a1daefbb2f41fb6fd7b8d695b8388939b96b6223f84d96920b01004d632103fd5d6af3e90c1f1f6c4980520b02937b68dbe5939e2401206ec45c17d06bdd8d6702f000b27521024af7c8cbcbe85ffaa4d3057f6573aabc97090247c371099fed96ab5ffac2edfe68ac00000000",
"blockheight": 836722,
"txindex": 225,
"locktime": 0,
"version": 2,
"inputs": [
{
"txid": "19e3daf96f323d3bd5b0b5de0bba690d50e51c9e8ce894bdd4d7167763203dff",
"index": 1,
"sequence": 240
}
],
"outputs": [
{
"index": 0,
"amount_msat": 36935000,
"scriptPubKey": "00144fa77385cb8be66e6419b0efd0f62e208a711b94"
}
]
},
`

`{
"hash": "599b95c2b03dc2ee4a8598014ab56f91c9cd46fec99559e181a7a34a43ae07ef",
"rawtx": "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",
"blockheight": 837114,
"txindex": 1482,
"locktime": 837088,
"version": 2,
"inputs": [
{
"txid": "19e3daf96f323d3bd5b0b5de0bba690d50e51c9e8ce894bdd4d7167763203dff",
"index": 0,
"sequence": 0
}
],
"outputs": [
{
"index": 0,
"amount_msat": 31509000,
"scriptPubKey": "0020c769f77d2c38056c5f09034644fce580b9654df889941f31754416fadb2445a7"
}
]
},
`

Contributor guide

No contributing guide indexed for this repository

Assessment

This issue has not been assessed yet.

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.