DomTheDeveloper / DomTheDeveloper/crl
Lean formalization bounty: Bernstein obstacle theorem package
@DomTheDeveloper is already working on this.
Since Jul 20, 2026.
- Dominant language
- Lean
- Stars
- 0
- Forks
- 1
- PR merge metrics
- No merged PRs in 30d
Description
Goal
Produce a faithful, pinned, no-sorry, axiom-audited Lean formalization of the corrected Bernstein–Bézier obstacle theorem package.
Staged public bounty schedule and current state
| Stage | Deliverable | Proposed project bounty | Current status |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Faithful paper-to-Lean statement specification | $5,000 | Substantially complete: theorem index and trust boundary published |
| 1 | One-dimensional Bernstein certificate bridge | $5,000 | Lean-verified |
| 2 | Clipping and downstream no-penetration theorem | $3,500 | Lean-verified |
| 3 | Simplicial Bernstein–Bézier and face/subdivision infrastructure | $20,000 | Core certificate/face/unisolvence layer Lean-verified; full geometric subdivision library remains expandable |
| 4 | Abstract convex/Mosco/variational-inequality layer | $30,000 | Lean-verified through projection/KKT, finite and assembled closedness/Mosco, energy identities and abstract convergence reductions |
| 5 | General finite-element Mosco and strong-minimizer theorem | $45,000 | Finite assembled endgame Lean-verified; moving Sobolev mesh spaces and concrete positive recovery remain open |
| 6 | Coefficient localization and conformity-preserving clipping repair | $60,000 | Corrected analytical proof complete under explicit local grading/broken-regularity assumptions; physical-mesh/free-boundary Lean realization open |
| 7 | Sharp H1 rate plus multiplier/energy/Falk proofs |
$60,000 | Corrected analytical proof complete under explicit assumptions; Lean realization open |
| 8 | Reproducibility, axiom audit, and independent faithfulness review | $20,000 | Machine audit/reproduction complete for the verified baseline; independent human faithfulness report open |
Total proposed staged project bounty: $248,500. These figures are project estimates, not verified market values or guaranteed funds.
Verified Lean baseline
- Branch:
review/bernstein-obstacle-v1 - Commit:
209460f762b24d05534075424a5a3864cc5edb9c - Successful Lean audit: run
29777931837 - Successful full reproduction: run
29777931942
This baseline remains immutable because the finite algebraic and abstract Hilbert-space layers are machine verified there.
Corrected analytical statement target
- Branch:
review/bernstein-obstacle-v2-corrected - Commit:
f2bd41f19ff5afbcca8a23f9afdcdf084364dae4 - Correction PR: #106
Any new theorem-correspondence work must compare the Lean baseline with the corrected v2 manuscript, especially the local-size risky set, one-ring grading, uniform broken regularity, and physical-boundary hypotheses. The analytical moving-Sobolev/free-boundary theorem is not claimed as fully formalized.
Current extension
PR #104 adds a coordinate-free real Hilbert-space layer:
- VI Pythagorean inequality;
- squared-distance error control;
- VI-to-metric-minimizer transfer;
- uniqueness of the Hilbert-space VI solution.
It targets review/bernstein-obstacle-v1 so the extension is reviewed against the immutable machine-verified baseline.
Remaining high-value formalization tasks
- Define a changing family of conforming simplicial finite-element spaces as subspaces of a fixed physical Sobolev/Hilbert space.
- Formalize nonnegative smooth density in
H_0^1 ∩ {v ≥ 0}. - Formalize the positive Bernstein sampling/recovery operator and its affine-element estimates.
- Prove the moving-cone Mosco recovery and weak-limit conditions in the physical space.
- Connect the abstract Hilbert-space VI theorem to the moving discrete minimizers.
- Formalize the corrected local-size risky set, one-ring grading, tubular free-boundary geometry, coefficient localization, strip measure and the
h_Gamma^(3/2)repair estimate. - Formalize the physical-boundary face/off-face split, multiplier consistency and the energy/Falk routes.
Acceptance requirements
Every paid milestone must include:
- a pinned Lean/mathlib revision;
- no
sorryand no undeclared project axioms; - explicit
#print axiomsregression tests; - deterministic build instructions;
- a theorem correspondence document proving statement faithfulness to v2;
- independent review before analytical theorem milestones are accepted.
These bounty values are project estimates, not claims of a universal market rate.
Contributor guide
No contributing guide indexed for this repository
First steps
- Read the whole issue, then the project's contributing guide.
- Comment on the issue to say you are picking it up — it saves two people doing the same work.
- Fork the repository and make your change on a branch.
- Open a pull request that references the issue number.
Assessment
This issue has not been assessed yet.