Comfy-Org / Comfy-Org/ComfyUI

Severe regression: workflow load rewrites node values (ckpt/lora and others), sometimes resetting to 0, destroying JSON integrity

Open
#13,017 34 comments 8 reactions 0 assignees View on GitHub
Dominant language
Python
Stars
133k
Forks
15.7k
Avg merge
1d 7h
Merged PRs (30d)
158

Description

### Summary

This is a severe regression that makes workflows unreliable.

When loading a workflow, node values are being silently rewritten.
This affects not only checkpoint/lora fields but also other nodes,
where values are unexpectedly reset (e.g. to 0).

Even worse, the original JSON is effectively destroyed after loading and saving.

---

### What happens

- Workflow JSON contains correct values
- Load workflow in ComfyUI
- Values are modified without user action:
- ckpt/lora replaced with different values
- some node parameters reset to 0
- Save workflow again
→ original data is permanently lost

---

### Expected behavior

- Workflow loader must preserve stored values exactly
- Missing resources should NOT trigger value replacement
- Invalid values can be marked, but never silently rewritten

---

### Actual behavior

- Values are rewritten during load
- Some nodes reset values (e.g. to 0)
- Workflow becomes non-reproducible
- JSON integrity is broken

---

### Reproduction (minimal)

1. Create a workflow with:
- CheckpointLoader / LoraLoader
- any node with numeric parameters
2. Save workflow
3. Modify JSON manually:
- set ckpt/lora to non-existent value
- set numeric fields to specific values
4. Load workflow

→ observe:
- ckpt/lora replaced
- some values reset (e.g. 0)
- after saving, original JSON is lost

---

### Impact

This completely breaks:
- workflow portability
- reproducibility
- archive reliability (PNG workflows)
- long-term project stability

This behavior makes ComfyUI workflows unsafe to use as saved artifacts.

---

### Notes

- This did NOT happen ~1 month ago
- This appears to be a regression in workflow loading / widget handling
- Not sure if this belongs to frontend or frontend/backend boundary

---

### Additional comment

This is not a minor issue.
If workflows cannot be trusted to preserve their own values,
it seriously undermines the usability of the entire project.

At this point, it feels like core functionality is breaking faster than it is being stabilized.

Contributor guide

Open the contributing guide

Assessment

This issue has not been assessed yet.

Get new issues in your inbox

A short digest of beginner-friendly GitHub issues.